Read Thread

Suggestions for improvements and additions to the site.

This feature was rejected 5/23/2007: rating is more important. If you don't have anything to say, we don't want to force a comment.

Rodney

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

You know how you get points from rating a game? Mabe you could get points for commenting on it, also.

solostrike

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

that one would have to be moderated (by mods :P) because i could paste the comment:

blah

and get points for it... but yes, another point should be given for comments...

October

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

But then there'd be demands for a trophy of commenting as well.

solostrike

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

not really... thats the same as rating basically...

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I agree

1 pt for rating
1 pt for commenting
-2 pts for comment deletion.

OOOO PRESSURES ON.

Rodney

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I didn;t know that you could delete comments.

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I am god. Actually demi-god.

Mods can delete comments and forum posts.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Great Idea, we need this. We will not need another trophy, but we will need a marker that tells you if you've commented, like we have for ratings.

Also, this post is my 400th!

October

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I support it. Although everybody who has already left a comment on a story (many people who both rate and comment) should get points for the ones they have already done.

Also, it should only be one point per one comment a storyame. As in you only get a point for the first comment you leave on a storygame.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Yes. I agree on both counts.

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Me too. But it should also include a double checkmarck on the games page. So now its 1 checkmark if u rated it. But it should be 2 if you commented and rated it. Just the second one if you just commented and just the first one if you just rated.

Rodney

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

And the check marks could be different colors to show what they are.

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Blue and Tan

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Red and Blue.

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I'd love to have the two cys colors actually.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Red and blue are MAG colours.

October

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I think that's what JJJ meant. He'd prefer CYS colours over MAG colours.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

MAG rules! I think CYS is... lame. It looks... well, dorky. MAG looks flashier, cleaner and displays cysid more! ohyeeeah!

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Anybody think this reminds them of me?

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

You use CYS. You've betrayed MAG and me, CYS... user! IS THERE ANYONE BESIDE ME WHO USES MAG!?

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Well actually I was a diehard mag fan. But there are some bugs with mag.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

The bugs are in CYS as well. They're just different graphics for the same data.

JJJ-thebanisher

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Hahah not true. Their are some seperate bugs..

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

Has anyone noticed the necromancy I performed with this thread!? This thread was from 2006!

October

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

It's not really necromancy. Necromancy would be somehow (got no idea) hacking into Alex's computer and taking off the 60 day reply limit, and then bringing something back. Which wouldn't be appreciated by Alex. In fact, I've probably got in trouble for just talking about it.

Still pretty awesome though.

Rommel

Points for commenting on a story

18 years ago

I wonder why alex hasn't accepted or rejected this in the 6 months it's been up...