Non-threaded

Forums » Writing Workshop » Read Thread

Find proofreaders here, useful resources, and share opinions and advice on story crafting.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

Hi. I'm currently writing a storygame right now, but I'd like to be sure that the first page is written well. Here are a few questions I'd like to ask about it:

-Did I explain the setting well?

-Is the plot introduced?

-Is the writing too tense, not tense enough, or just right?

-Should the backstory, reflections, and memory be left as-is, omitted, or put in different spots?

Here is my first page to my story (Note that items are used in the story):

You wake up to a knock on your door. This was part of the routine of a typical Tuesday for you: You would be woken up by your mom knocking on your door, get dressed, brush your teeth, eat breakfast while watching the news, and get on the bus for school. You open your eyes and look around you to see the items in your room: you were laying on a metal spring mattress which sat on the worn, dirty carpet of your house. The tan paint in your room was starting to peel and the door of your room was cheap and worn. Your clothes sat in a cheap brown dresser which stood only a couple feet away from you. Your room was small and only had one small, single-paned window. You then get out of your bed and put on a pair of blue jeans with holes in them, a tan-colored shirt with holes, and a pair of holy socks. You then opened the door, which led to a dimly-lit hallway with peeling paint. You then walked down to the right to another room, the bathroom. In the bathroom, you brushed your teeth, then went down a set of narrow, warping stairs to make breakfast for yourself. So far, it was a normal Tuesday for you.


 

The Tuesday remained normal until you and your mother began to watch the news on your family's staticky TV.  A lady on the news began to talk,


 

"And for a new developing story, a young eight-year old girl named Cheyanna Kovoski from Westmanville went missing last night. She was last seen at Westmanville Elementary School and has not been seen since then. Since there's currently a shortage in search and rescue teams, only a couple police officers are searching for her, which is increasing debates about the police budget. If you have any information about her, please call us,"


 

At first, it doesn't sink in that Cheyanna, your younger sister, just went missing. But the moment that it sinks it, it hits you like a bomb. Your very own sister went missing. She may be dead already, or worse. She could be tortured, raped, sold, or just about anything else. Your mother then breaks into tears as she starts talking.


 

"I didn't know how to tell you. I really didn't know how to tell you," she says in a voice with a European accent. "I wasn't expecting this to happen in America, that's exactly why we moved here,"


 

When she brings up moving, you then remember that when you were a child, your mother snuck into the United States as an immigrant from Bosnia when you were only three. When this happened, your mother gave up all her possessions trying to get into the US, which she viewed as a safe place with plenty of opportunity. Your father was unable to go because your family didn't have enough money to get the whole family across safely, and to this day, you haven't seen your father for nine years. When you arrived with your mother, you both discovered your mother was pregnant with a second child: Cheyanna. The moment Cheyanna pops back into your mind, you ask your mother a question.


 

"Mom, should I still go to school today?" you ask,


 

"Yes," she says. "I'm afraid there's nothing we can do to help Cheyanna right now. After all, she's a lower priority because we're poor."


 

"Because we're poor?"


 

"Yes, because we're poor. The rich are able to buy themselves into safety and protection, but we don't have that option. We have to work for our safety, but these times are tough. All my efforts to get a job have struck out in favor of hiring teens from richer places so they can have some cash to spend on fancy gadgets for their smartphones. The only option I have is to be a housekeeper, but around here, nobody's rich enough to afford a housekeeper. And to add on, I have no way of getting to the richer areas quickly because I don't even have a bike, let alone a car."


 

You then exit the house to see a run-down exterior with peeling paint, dead bushes, a caving roof, and a severely cracked driveway. This is where you waited for the bus every day. However, your mind starts to think about Cheyanna, and suddenly, the idea of trying to find her pops into your mind. Immediately when you think of her, you then look back to your house. In all its disrepair, it's still home, and you start to imagine the days you and Cheyanna would get in water balloon fights while encased in the rusty fence that surrounded your backyard. You imagined the days you and Cheyanna played patty-cake on the steps leading to the door of your house. You imagined the days you brought some soup your mother cooked up to Cheyanna in the days she was sick. You then realize, she needs you. She leans on you. But is the search for Cheyanna too much of a risk to your life?


 

As you continue to think, you open your backpack to greet some of the things you usually bring to school. However, as you open your backpack, you notice that you set your backpack on one of those change purses eight-year-old girls like to carry around while bragging that they're rich. You then look at the name tag attached to it. It has KOVOSKI written on it in all-caps with Sharpie. You don't recall yourself owning one of these, so you assume it's Cheyanna's.

 

 

Thanks for any feedback.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

Hey, so far I do believe it is written well. If you're looking for grammar fixes, I do see some simple mistakes.

For example, this line: "You then get out of your bed and put on a pair of blue jeans with holes in them, a tan-colored shirt with holes, and a pair of holy socks." - It should read holey socks, if you're going to use hole as an adjective. However, there is some debate on whether or not "holey" is a word. (http://grammarist.com/spelling/holey-holy/)

Another example here: "And for a new developing story, a young eight-year old girl named Cheyanna Kovoski from Westmanville went missing last night." - There should be a comma after Cheyanna Kovoski, because it is a name interjected into the sentence, clarifying the identity of the before mentioned girl.

Most of the other grammatical issues I see are comma splices. There's also the tense shift midway through. The beginning is in past tense, and the end is in present tense.

Now for content. Your premise is great. I do believe that you have a nice setup for a tense and intriguing story. However, there may be too much "talking," and not enough "showing." Some of the explanations seem out of place. Maybe get more involved in the story first? Also, how does the main character not realize the sister is missing? To report a missing person and have them featured on the news, they must have been missing for some time. I believe the rule in the US is 48 hours.

I honestly would love to play this storygame once it's complete.

 

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

48 hours only applies to an adult. Of course in a society where they just have two cops very casually strolling around as the only response  to a missing elementary school aged child, who knows.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

It appears my original post was wrong. 48 hours does not apply to adults or children, granted there is evidence of foul play (in the case of adults), even then, apparently you can file a missing person report immediately.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago
In case anyone was wondering...

For adults, this is because you can pack your bags and leave in the middle of the night without so much as a word to your friends or family. Huzzah for freedom. Anyway, that's not a crime nor a police matter, hence why one most provide reasonable cause to believe the "missing" adult is in danger and did not wander off on his/her own volition.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

1.) The setting's fine, got a little bit of a dystopian flavor, and that does get used so much now it can fall into cliches if you're not careful, but you didn't get too over the top with it. The only issue that stands out to me with how it's introduced is that the mother's dialogue  is seriously awkward and unnatural, like, almost hilariously so, and pretty obviously just exists to serve as an infodump.

2.) The plot is pretty obviously going to be about figuring out what happened to your sister, but the thing that wasn't set up at all was what the player's choices would be and where a kid is even going to start in searching for his sister.

The coin purse is going to have a clue, okay, but, but at the end of this page the player is still going to expect to be able to make some sort meaningful decision. And 'go to school (and end the game) or search for your sister (to keep playing)' doesn't really count just fyi.

3.) This is the area that needs the most work. The first paragraph in particular; that's maybe the most important part of your story as far as actually catching a reade's attention hours, and it's the weakest part of this whole page. Right now it's a definite issue the story is spending as much time trying to make us care about the wallpaper in the kid's room as the kid themself or their entire family. (Just the fact that I had to awkwardly phase that sentence with 'themself' is a good indicator of a detail that is lacking, as well as a name and some idea of their age and what they look like.)

There are more concise ways to get across that they're poor. You really don't need an entire paragraph dedicated to spelling this out, and so many of the details given are unnecessary and just...well, the phrasing needs work. Try reading that while paragraph out loud to yourself, and mix up the 'You do this' You then do this' 'You then do this' sentences you have there a little.

4.) Hard to give as clear cut an answer on this one, since it ties so much into the other three. I'd say just don't set your mind on keeping it exactly how you have it, and in the course of reworking the rest of the page and the next few you might find more natural places to include those.

If I were to make any specific suggestion for a change in the series of events here, I'd suggest not waiting for the news broadcast to introduce the fact that the protag even has a sister. Honestly, I'd probably drop the news reveal altogether. I know that's often used as a way to make Dramatic Revelations on movies or TV, but when you're writing that kind of scene out you really have to know what you're doing and be very familiar with actual news broadcasts to make it sound realistic. (Who even uses 'staticky' TV now, btw? Let alone whatever near future this is set in. TVs don't actually work that way anymore...)

Anyway, the mother would be a better source of the reveal here. This would give her some much needed personality and a chance to show some actual emotion at the kidnapping of her daughter. Because right now, basically nothing about her reaction seems even remotely realistic.

 

 

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

Would you say that another page set the day before this page would help? I'm thinking about adding a page that would explain that Cheyanna was supposed to go to her friend's house to play after school on the day she went missing. I'm thinking it would add some sort of an extra hint on a place to go to ask for info. And maybe the character went to bed before Cheyanna was supposed to get back, so that way the reveal could be the next day (and by the mother). However, I might slip the info about the lack of police searching for Cheyanna in.

I know I didn't confirm this, but the character is twelve (which will be important later). There isn't really a set age or gender to the protagonist as of yet, but I do plan to work on developing them (and all the other characters).

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

No time for a long response right now, but that separate page to set things up and let readers get to know the characters a little may be a good idea, you're trying to cram a lot in here.

It might be worthwhile for you to do some reading on the subject or even talk to an adult about what they'd do or how they'd react if a child that age went missing. For instance, it's highly doubtful mom would be so casual about the whole thing, or leave it to her twelve year old to take the obvious steps of talking to the friend (or parent of the friend) whose house she was supposed to have been at.  Unless the idea is that the mom is neglectful or out of touch in some way, life is not just going to carry on as normal and she'd be doing everything possible to find her child, so realistically you may need to have her have more of a role in the story than you might have planned.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

I second Mizal on her suggestion of including the mom as a more integral piece of the storyline.

However, an alternate route would be to have the mom doing everything she could legally, going through the proper channels and such, and the player becoming frustrated with the lack of progress. The character could set out on their own to do some "vigilante work" to help find the sister. However, the problem with this is the character's age. At 12, he/she cannot drive, does not have a self-generated income source, and therefore is limited in what he/she can do to help police. This character is also limited in that they must attend school, and cannot "call in sick," or take some personal time to  investigate the sister's disappearance.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

At 12, one can most definitely ditch school.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

HECK YEAH!

I heard rumors about this one girl who ditched so she could meet her friends in the park and talk all day. Talk about freedom!

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

You've heard rumors? So, not only have you never done it, but no one you know has done it?

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

Yes
No I have not
Yes

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

True, but if this is taking place in the US, calls are sent out every morning through an automated system to alert parents of students not in school. Miss too many days, and the authorities/social services step in. Granted, these parents would likely be more focused on the missing daughter, but questions may come up, and the parents would likely be upset that their child is putting themselves in danger, rather than letting police do their job (if we're going by my suggested scenario). Also, what good is missing school if you can't drive anywhere? Setting would come into place. There are many cities/states without major public transportation (including my home town).

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

1. The mum can have to go to work, kid can stay home "sick", leave.

2. OK... just base it somewhere where they is great public transport.

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

"The mum can have to go to work, kid can stay home "sick", leave."
Step 1: Complain about stomach issue
Step 2: Purposefully heat up your forehead with lamp, blow dryer, hot bowl of ramen, etc.
Step 3: Take temp
Step 4: Display for all to see
Step 5: Skip school
"OK...just base it somewhere where they is great public transport."
Step 1: Write a book
Step 2: Write a book for your book
Step 3: Book a vacation for your book's book
Step 4: Mail it to Africa

Is This Page Written Well?

7 years ago

I got the sense it wasn't meant to be in just a normal modern day seeing, though, if the premise of the whole thing is that the police are barely even bothering to investigate, and may not have the resources even if they wanted too. Turkey hadn't said too much about the details of the setting, but if things are that bad with the police department it'd be believable enough that other public services are going to shit. 

IRL, social services may have been looking at that family already if it's just a normal thing for the kids to show up every day in literal rags.  Make society in general give less of a fuck about what 12 year olds get up to and he suddenly has more freedom to work with.