Player Comments on It's Raining Again

**Contains Spoilers**

I thought the story was extremely well-written. It was short and simple, and yet the tone and general feel was something that drew me in. I realize that sentence was poorly stated so allow me to elaborate. This story is short. The author’s description states it. The play length is aptly set. It will take no time at all to get through the entire thing and that actually adds to it! But wait, how can not having a lot of words on a page actually add to the story? Great question, [insert your name here]. The general feel of the story is emptiness. Everyone is dead except you. The love of your life is dead. There are no other people. None at all! The pages were barely filled with words and it only reminded me of how lonely of a world this was.

The backstory instantly immersed me into this lonely world. You learn two things right away: there was a plague epidemic and witchcraft is punishable by death. It’s a grim, chaotic world and you get the feeling that death was abundant. It felt like unraveling a tapestry. The choices that you make reveal the picture little by little. Although it seems impossible to lose, there are multiple endings so the game element is included by searching for them all.

Things that stuck out to me:

- The first sentence is the title of the story. Well duh, anyone would notice that. No shit, [insert same name as above]. I like it when the title of a book or movie is mentioned in the content. I think we can all agree it’s oddly satisfying.

- The first page has a really long sentence that goes on and on and seems like it would be better off split into two because it read a bit awkwardly even when read multiple times. It’s actually not that bad, but I did find it awkward.

- Suspense is heavily built on the first page.

- There are plenty of references. I caught the mention of BerkaZerka, which made me think there could be more cameos of CYS members. You’d have live under a rock or be 5 years old not to catch the Rolling Stones reference. Not sure if “Muddy Waters” was meant to reference the blues artist. I’d like to think so. There’s a line that includes the phrase “more than a feeling” possibly referencing the song by Boston. Maybe I’m reading into it too deep, idk.

- When it rains in movies, something bad is about to happen. This kept the same theme.

This was a nice reminder that a good, well-written storygame doesn’t have to be a 500k page epic. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Reading the story description, I’m not sure about how to comment, review, or rate this story. You’re mentioning that it’s not supposed to be much, but you did write with a number of endings in just four hours. With only 1,400 words, this is clearly going to be quite short, and with five endings, even shorter (unless all the endings are off one page). So I guess as I head into this review, my expectations are a bit low, which it appears you expect as well.

Okay, I’m not sure about the first four pages. They are all very short and have no choices. They aren’t even at really good breaking points, to be honest. If there were a scene change related to the breaks, that would at least make a little sense, but in this case I can’t really see why they’re not all one page, other than just trying to inflate your page count.

Next up is the “choices” page. I’ve seen this type of setup before, where the reader is actually forced to choose every option on page. I think it can work okay for a couple choices, but for four choices, well, there’s not really a choice there, is there? How different would the story read if there were simply four consecutive pages with that information? Of course, in that case, I’d likely complain that the story was too linear without choices. Then again, I think it is fair to call these choices false choices because it clearly doesn’t matter which one you choose or what order you choose them, you still have to choose them all.

I played it a few times and can see the effects of the scripting and the effects of that other actual choices. Yes, the scripting works. Is it a competent story? Well, there’s no glaring tense or grammatical errors, if that’s what you’re asking. Is it much of a story? Not really, but clearly you knew that when you published it. Is it decent for a four-hour attempt? I would say yes, it isn’t bad for four hours of work. Is it something people should feel a desire or need to read? Maybe not so much. So nicely done with the purpose you had in mind, but there’s not much more there!

This was really well written and definitely had those choose your own adventure vibes mixed in a grimer sense.

What I think is most effectively executed is the tone. The world feels empty and cold, and the two endings I got felt consistent with the choices I'd made. Of course, it is rather short, but its time is spent well and I enjoyed my experience with it. Great job, Bucky!

Well, I rated 5 out of 8. It was more like a story than an adventure game, but it was very well written and it told the reader the lovers' feelings throughly. I would not be saying it's bad, nor it's an excellent piece. If I have to leave a little phrase for this....
Good job.

It was amazing

I now feel a deep urge to paint my room black.
Anyway, it is a good, quick read that I enjoyed. The setting and description are very clear, and it is not hard to picture the world it is set in.

sob

Well, the story was great. It’s incredibly well-written and very thorough for such a short piece. However, there weren’t really any choices. It didn’t feel like anything I did would have any effect on the ending.

Damn, this was good. I had it in my saves for a while and finally got around to reading it. Great writing Bucky!

I personally did not like this and I would not recommend this to anything. I feel attacked tbh.

Not really Impactful, but still interesting.

amazing

I wish there were more choices. I enjoyed the story though!

Definitely a style of its own, almost poetic. Not my particular cup of tea, but still interesting. Has Mr. Jagger given his critique?

Ha.... well you seem to like The Rolling Stones. Pretty good.... I guess... I wouldn't call it competent, but it ain't bad. Only people who know The Rolling Stones would understand the measure of humor in this game.

Palepaper are you even a real person? That's a Rolling Stones reference

If you really pay attention to the story it does tug on your heart slightly. What really spoke to me was wanting to rid of the colors. Could use improvement as all things do but enjoyable none the less.

Obviously a little on the short side but well written and works for what it was. You did a nice job establishing the setting and the character's mental state with few words. I've been experimenting around with the idea of 'flash CYOAs' so this is of interest to me for that reason too.


The means of triggering endings was a little too obvious so it may have taken away from the experience to repeatedly hitting restart and going to select a different option just to see all the text, but any coherent story in four hours is impressive. Mission accomplished as far as proving a passable story is not hard to write. The difficulty probably lies more in being able to identify what is and isn't a manageable plot in a short timeframe. Seems like a lot of the last minute entrants bit off more than they could chew, myself included.