Player Comments on Scum

Well this had a lot of potential and it was a good attempt, but it fell short of what I was looking for when this was assigned to you for the contest.

Still, I always like a story with a villain protagonist so I didn’t hate it, it was just more of a case that this story could have went in all sorts of directions.

And that was the main problem I had with it, so many pages are linked in a linear fashion so it doesn’t really feel like there is much choice and that’s a major flaw for a CYOA. Might have even been better to shorten the amount of paths you had set and focus on a couple with more choices.

I didn’t really have too much of a problem with anything else concerning the story. Some of the characters probably could have been fleshed out a bit more, but they were fine in the scheme of things.

Personally I’d like to see you go back to this one and rework some of it. Add more choices, fix things, etc. Long shot that’s going to happen, but as I said the story has a lot more potential than just its current form.
-- EndMaster on 6/23/2018 1:25:26 PM with a score of 0
Bonny and Clyde ending.

I enjoyed reading this, and the amount of options and word count is really 'impressive.'(to quote Steve)

This being said, there are a few glaring things to be improved upon.

1.Choices: There were a fair amount of choices, and the choices made meant something in the grand scope of the story. There was so much constantly going on, that I found myself wanting choices more often. Like I felt that there were a lot of choices that I should have been able to make, but I wasn't. It didn't necessarily take away from the story, but it definitely could have made it better.

2. Characters: I feel like this area was lacking quite a bit. I found myself not really caring about any of the characters aside from my self. Fleshing them out would significantly boost your story.

3: General Writing: Among my criticisms, this is perhaps the one you should take the most from imo. There were a ton of sentences that could have been cut down a size, and, as a result, the flow of the story was often interrupted. Saying sentences out loud would help a ton in this regard. If it doesn't sound right out loud, then it doesn't read right when read. Also, try and make sure to cut out the irrelevant parts of the pages. I often found myself reading things that didn't contribute anything. If these things had been better, then your story would have increased several notches.

To some it all up. It was good, but it could be significantly better.
-- EbonVasilis on 1/9/2018 3:19:26 PM with a score of 0
Well, this was an interesting storygame. It's clear you put the effort in with a very impressive 50k in little over a month, which is a very impressive feat. For the amount of quantity you were spurning out, it holds an impressive quality. The actual story and setting seemed pretty interesting, I've always had a preference for the less than moral protagonists and conventional villains. Thankfully, EndMaster's prompt seemed to give a fairly good setting for you, rather than some brutal joke on his part and at your expense. The world seemed cool, although things like the various aliens could've used far more description, since all I knew was from the earlier briefing they weren't humanoid, and from the description that they were seven foot and blue. The actual amount of content in the whole thing was very impressive, with what I think was three solid branches breaking off from the very start of the game, which was a very ballsy choice and meant you practically had a few smaller games shoved into one. Still, despite and perhaps because of this there was also quite a bit lacking in choice in some of the paths, even meaningless choice or choice that would lead to death, and even at bits that felt like they deserved them, like sticking with Alyssa and getting sent on a suicide mission for it, with several stretches of like seven or eight links without choices, but given time shortages and how quickly you let the game branch out at the start, that seems understandable. Still, adding a few meaningless or death choices would've at least made it seem a bit less railroad-y.

My favorite path was definitely the pirate path. I liked trying to convince the pirate captain that my murdering of the other captain was justified, that was one of the cooler parts of the game.

I feel you try far too hard to tread the whole edgy line. Like, there isn't swearing for dramatic effect, or even swearing because people swear, but at point's it seems like there's just swearing for swearing's sake. Now, I love swearing, but there's a point where you're trying a bit too hard. Like, evil, scumbag characters don't need to impart that they're evil and scum with every single sentence, they can have elements besides that, but in this, it seemed rather than trying to create a three-dimensional protagonist who was a scumbag, you just went hard with the scum element, making the protagonist more of just a cunt rather than a likable villain.

There also tended to be a fair bit of sentences that kind of just ran on as you tried to impart a lot of information that a lot of times, wasn't even relevant, like with "Fuck that, you weren't about to get sucked into the vacuum of space if those aliens got a lucky shot in the hull like in the case of the U.S.S Panther which was the first ship of your fleet to have fallen." The sentence doesn't flow the best, and I feel most of it isn't even imparting information I need. I don't need to know the U.S.S Panther was the first ship to go, I don't even need to know the aliens need a lucky shot to take the ship down, if anything, that seems counter-intuitive, as the situation is supposed to be going to shit, but the enemy needing lucky shots seems like it's in our favor. Anyhow, just an example. There was also some very weird phrasing I didn't understand. Like, getting up from your "manned seat" confused the shit out of me. Aren't all seats manned? What other purpose for a seat is there?

Anyhow, it was a cool game, and a very enjoyable setting. My endings were Natives, Filthy Spy and A Pirates Life for me.

Ultimately, I thought it was a pretty interesting game, although there was perhaps too much of a focus on length and word count over other things, and a few flaws, but nothing that can't be worked on. I'm not sure how well it fitted the prompt, given that I think the longest path of a Native doesn't even have the colony until the end, and you're not really a villain, just kind of an edgy native hero, and in the other option, you really only ran from pirates until the end where you decided to mess with the colony, but that's for the judges. I liked the game, I thought it was cool and an interesting setting, and it's good competition to face off against in this big contest. Well done on this, hopefully it'll do well for you in the contest.
-- Steve24833 on 1/9/2018 9:07:44 AM with a score of 0
My ending was shock and awe. The plot of the story was interesting, however, the style of the narrative feel rushed and is really linear. Sometimes the main character contradicts himself. I liked the natives' politics and overall design. They are same time alien and credible, and the npc are fleshed out even if the description is not very detailed.

My favourite character was Alissa who seems very interesting but there is not really dialogue with her or choices to how to deal with her. And that is my major criticism. Linearity is barely interactive and feels like you have no agency over anything happening.

It feels unpolished, but. have great potential if someday you polish it.
-- poison_mara on 10/8/2019 3:07:00 AM with a score of 0
Surprisingly good. Liked the plot. Wished an epilogue was available.
-- Axel on 9/1/2018 12:46:43 PM with a score of 0
Forgot to mention, my first ending was Native
-- Victim on 2/8/2018 5:10:21 PM with a score of 0
It’s one in many storygames of this genre, and it doesn’t do anything to stand out. It’s very well-written, but there’s not much else to be said about it. 5/8
-- Victim on 2/7/2018 9:04:01 PM with a score of 0
I got the shock and awe ending, accidentally clicked the wrong rating, will go and correct.
-- corgi213 on 1/15/2018 7:05:49 PM with a score of 0
I got the ending spy
It was good but would of been nice though if I could of conquered/destroyed the rest of the colonies but considering how long the story can be and the branches with the little time the person wrote it you wouldn't expect it.
-- Euel on 1/9/2018 6:33:42 PM with a score of 0
This was overall a pretty decent story. I went through most of the endings and it kept me reading for a while. As per your request, the first ending I received was Bloody Sonars. One small problem I noticed is when given the choice between a cell with others or by yourself, both lead to the same result - might have a small linking problem there. I felt like the choices were a bit random at times (1/2, left/right) and a lot of the pages also didn't have choices, but overall the story itself was rather enjoyable.
-- StillWatersRunDeep on 1/8/2018 5:55:15 PM with a score of 0
Now I’m ded :(
-- LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL on 1/8/2018 3:58:09 PM with a score of 0
I got native Ending
-- Noob_Master on 1/8/2018 3:52:06 PM with a score of 0
I got a pirates life for me.
-- LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL on 1/8/2018 3:40:41 PM with a score of 0
Pretty damn good, kick-ass game with a good POV and only a few capitalization errors. Good Job!
-- Noob_Master on 1/8/2018 3:36:41 PM with a score of 0
Close Window