Non-threaded

Forums » Feature Wishing Well » Read Thread

Suggestions for improvements and additions to the site.
This feature was rejected 10/22/2008: Didn't like any of them; we'll keep as is.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

Can we change it's name? a 4 is not actually that bad. Here is how I see the ratings:

1,2,3 - a crummy game

4,5 - a medium game

6,7 -a great game

8 -YOU MUST PLAY

Note that a 4 1/2 is halfway, so a four should say something similar to 5. Like: "A nice alternative to homework". A 4 is not a bad game, but some people think that all games 4 and below are shit. That is not true. Strictly speaking, only the 1s are shit. The 4s NEED to be renamed.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Who cares how you see it.  Moved to B&P this is not a feature.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

we should all care about what our members say 3j. whether you deem it stupid or not is irrelevant. its up to alex.

note: i will delete any further childishness between the 2 of you.

as for the idea, decent idea rommel, but very small in terms of importance.

nate

The "4" rating

17 years ago

So our posts are childish but the one Im replying to is not?

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Suggesions for a new #4?

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Not sure, but I think the #5's type would work well "not the best, certainly not the worst". Of course, then we'd have to think up a new #5...  but #4 and #5 need to be middling... so #5's current type's feel... maybe "a cut above the magazines/comics/newspapers/JJJ"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
A cut above the JJJ:S

The "4" rating

17 years ago

4. not too good, not too bad

Riley

The "4" rating

17 years ago
4. Interesting, but not that interesting.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

How about these?

"A game that's worth somewhat more than $2"

"Choose your own fun"

"A good read"

"Letters, Good Plots and Words, Oh My!"

"Perfect for a rainy afternoon"

"Alleviates Boredom"

"Worth Mentioning"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Meh
Meh
Meh
Meh
OK
Good
Meh

The "4" rating

17 years ago

"The Norm"

"Average"

"C"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Meh
Meh
Suckky

The "4" rating

17 years ago
"kills time well"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
"A much better option than homework"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
 How about "We changed it to this so rommel would sut up about the 4 rating." lol, jk.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

"Better than anything DarthVader_13 did"

(sorry, but if you join JJJ's dark side...)

The "4" rating

17 years ago

I said i was kidding... and besides, surviving school was in honourable mentions in the contest... it didn't win because it wasn't spell checked. So iI pretty much won the classic editor contest.

riley

The "4" rating

17 years ago
4-5 is in the middle, so that should be avg, so i agree with rommels first post (can u tell i havent read anything else in this thread :P)

The "4" rating

17 years ago

MY DARK SIDE? MINE! AWWEH THANKS.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Yeah... the dark side of MAG, "a crummy world of plotholes and spelling errors"-Fry

The "4" rating

17 years ago
A plot with holes is better then any of your games...

The "4" rating

17 years ago

...Is there a specific plot that we're talking about here?

Riley

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Yeah which of my plots has holes...

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Not really plot-holes, but the only good games you've made are Tower and Matt(h)ias, and Matt(h)ias is still a world of spelling errors. Also: DONT MAKE ANY MORE QUIZZES OR SPORT GAMES! THEY ALL SUCK!!!

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Hockey Fantasy Pool was actually pretty good in my opinion, even though I hardly know the sport and don't know who the hell the players are, it was fun putting together a random team.

But yeah, the quizzes weren't that good in my opinion. I can only determine whether they are good or not for myself. I can't just say they're crap and they're automatically crap. It depends on what you think of it.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
I liked Drafted to the Predators alot.  Its Quite Unique.  Well I like it alot because It was my first real game.  And Rommel I'l do whatever I Danmed please! If I wanna make 50 more quizzes I will.  AND The Tower is not that bad on spelling mistakes although MATTIAS  (no H) is.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Deleted Rommels post.  No flaming please.  Threatening is not acceptable and will not be tolerated.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Who was he flaming, just out of interest? It wasn't me, was it?

The "4" rating

17 years ago

No, t'was rommel.

Deleted another threat Although it was more subtle.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
How 'bout...

4 = "Well, I've seen worse."
Or maybe that'd be more of a 3.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

"keep 'em coming"

The "4" rating

17 years ago

or

4 = Good but not as good as a peanut better and jelly sandwich.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

Noithing is as good as a PB&J sandwich.

Riley

The "4" rating

17 years ago
I dunna you might change your mind when you hit puberty ::D

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Bleugh! peanut butter and jam/jelly? That's DISGUSTING! Now chocolate sandwiches....

The "4" rating

17 years ago
I LOVE PBJ

The "4" rating

17 years ago

stick with what you want, I like delicious butter-and-sugar pancakes... glaaar....

Seriously, they're really sweet.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
I LOVE THOSE THINGS

The "4" rating

17 years ago

I've just had some... glaaaar....

anyway, back on topic:

 "Yon ancient tomes of forgotten lore cannot compete!"

"If MAG were a battlefield, you would be the tanks...."

"Worth a shot"

The "4" rating

17 years ago
"Better then a nickel but worse then a Dime"

The "4" rating

17 years ago

"Run-of-the-mill"

"Average, Average, Average..."

"All Homework is conquered, let the games begin..."

The "4" rating

17 years ago
The one referring to better than a nickel isn't that good. Most countries don't have the same currency.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Actually, I've got my own list for ratings. Just some brainstorming.

1: You need to look up "good storygame" in the dictionary.
2: I know dogs that made better games.
3: Well, I've seen worse.
4: Not the best, certainly not the worst.
5: It's actually enjoyable.
6: It's almost better than peanut butter sandwich!
7: I love it like my own mother!
8: It rivals the work of God.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

Here's mine!

1: Forget the tip, this stuff needs to be shredded and burned!

2:Slightly more fun than taking advanced nuclear hyperbolic topology exams with a headache

3: Bad author, no doughnut!

4: Not the best, certainly not the worst

5:If MAG were a battlefield, you would have some pretty big guns

6:Better than yon mystic tomes of thy ancient, forgotten lore

7:It's worth every cent

8:May bliss eternal come to the author of this masterpiece

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Those are pretty good, but...
1.) Some of them need explanation and contemplation to understand.
and 2.) They're just too long.

I'm not being mean, but you need to make them short and sweet and easy to understand.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

ANUBIS YOURS ARE THE MOST AMAZING EVER, JUST SWITCH 1 AND 2

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Seeing we're all doing our own set of ratings, I have mine.

1 - You'd have more fun jumping off a cliff.
2 - Slightly better than homework.
3 - Don't tire your eyes on this.
4 - Average
5 - A good time-waster
6 - Better than paperclip fights.
7 - It rivals the work of Gods.
8 - It will bring you enlightenment.

Sorry, Anubis. I liked your rivalling God's idea, so I used it for seven. Hope you don't mind.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Sorry doc. Oct.  Nub's is better.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
JJJ, I see where 1 and 2 on my list could be switched.

As for you October, I liked your 1 one. "You'd have more fun jumping off a cliff." That's good. But yours are just, well, not funny enough. NO OFFENSE, no offense. You're still cool. And so is "You'd have more fun jumping off a cliff." LOL. That's priceless.

Oh crap, I typed LOL. Now JJJ's gonna have a seizure, L--no, wait.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
1: You'd have more fun jumping off a cliff.
2: I know dogs that made better games.
3: Well, I've seen worse.
4: These games define the average.
5: It's actually enjoyable.
6: It's almost better than peanut butter and jelly sandwich!
7: I love it like my own mother!
8: It rivals the work of God.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
3: Bad Author, no doughnut!

The "4" rating

17 years ago
That doesn't make any sense, Rommel. "Well, I've seen worse" is better. Because it's true. Usually.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
BAD AUTHOR NO DONUGHT THATS GREAT HAHAHAHAHHAH

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Sorry Rommel we're really uptight about spam in the FWW.  Post deleted.

The "4" rating

17 years ago

4: Hmm... meh...

The "4" rating

17 years ago
That could work.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Heh, because it has "meh" in it. It could work huh... yeah, it could work.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
I don't like 6 and 7. I only know a few people who like peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. And it's bad to compare a storygame to your mother (because you either love her or hate her).

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Well it says I love it like...

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Oh.. that might mean AWESOME GAME YOU CAN'T MISS gets a seven from some people. I don't really mind that one, I just hate the peanut butter and jelly sandwich one. I probably won't mind anything that goes there except the peanut butter and jelly one.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Oh yeah thats interesting.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
This is just to decide the new 4, but a new seven would be really good, something everyone can relate to. I have no idea what "Reeses Cups" means. Also, Peanut butter and jam is a disgusting combination. Now chocolate sandwiches... Glaaar....

The "4" rating

17 years ago
YOU DONT KNOW WHAT REESES PEENUT BUTTER CUPS ARE?

The "4" rating

17 years ago
NO YOU FOOL. I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT REESES FRIGGIN' CUPS ARE! If they are a snack, I don't think they released them in OZ.  See if Miccy2000 has heard of them.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Even I've heard of them, Rommel. I haven't tasted them though, and I do agree with you on the fact that seven should be changed.

I always thought Alex just had an advertising deal or something with Reeses Cups.

The "4" rating

17 years ago
Ugh Reeses Cups. They taste gross I had them up in Brisbane coz they dont sell them down here.
Seriously, if u want better chocolate, try some cheap brand crap from Cheap as Chips or whatever they call it up in the USA/ other countries

The "4" rating

17 years ago

4: Just play the game already!

7: Not the best, but veeery close!

The "4" rating

16 years ago
4: Instant game, just add nerds/players/water/beer/MAG/CYS

The "4" rating

15 years ago
Here's mine:

1: Eww!
2: Yuk!
3: Ick.
4: Meh.
5: Huh!
6: Wow!
7: Hey!
8: Woo-hoo!

The "4" rating

15 years ago
Uuuuhhh...

EPIC FAIL
lulz