Making choices obviously plays a large role in CYS, if not, the biggest role. I figure the best kind of decisions to be made in a CYOA are the hardest ones. Try to brainstorm some tough descisions below, or if there are some pre-existing difficult descisions in a story, be sure to share those too.
I'll go first: A loved one just suffered from a physical accident where they remain unconscious in the hospital. The doctor says that they can be revived, but to do so they would have to break every single bone in their body. The doctor asks the player to decide.
P.S. I guess this could also be thought of a 'Would you rather?' Sort of post.