Player Comments on Cantina Band: The Assassins' New Tune

Onto the sequel! I quite enjoyed this. Once again, here's what I thought:

- Okay, the description has gotten better, which is actually one of the criticisms I had of the first one, but could still be expanded a little more at the start. Later on it kind of developed.

- While there were fewer spelling issues, I noticed a fair amount of incorrect dialogue syntax, which I don't think I saw before, including on the first page. For example:
"Tell me what you know about the IG-88 droids working for Zuckuss"
You need a full stop ('period', though I think I saw British English so ignore that if you're from the Motherland) at the end of these sentences, or a comma when the sentence continues, e.g. when it explains who is saying it and how they're saying it. I did notice you put commas after the double quotation marks, but they need to go before. However, leave them out if you use elipses, exclamation marks, or question marks. This was pretty common throughout, but is a pretty minor fault.
- "Clash! Clee! Cling! Krrrrrr!" Some improved sound effects, though I didn't think 'clee' was even possible before reading this. Still, it does look like you've stopped mashing the keyboard with one hand, so that's good.

- The warning about the continuation from your first game doesn't look nice sitting inside the story. I'd suggest writing it in the description and just quickly mentioning that people need to choose the correct path in the first to understand the second.

- While I was originally glad to see you'd added items, the hologram projector is completely useless as one. Actually, none of them are actually usable as far as I can tell apart from the chitin armour. You put a fair amount of time describing and finding pictures for the decent number of weapons, but I didn't get to use any of them in the fight! Instead of picking it up and then just showing what it says on the next page, I'd suggest making the reader have to click 'Use Item', and have the effect on that page lead to the page where it shows the information on who to recruit. A useful article on how to do that kind of thing is here: http://chooseyourstory.com/help/articles/article.aspx?ArticleId=2, though it looks like you know how to use item effects already.

- Haha the freeze gun's picture was just Han Solo's frozen face though so that makes up for the strange use of items. The heavy weapons could have done with pictures too, as well as the sniper and money items, and only one had a description that acknowledged the reader's choice from the Mos Eisley shop. This is minor as well.

- Onto my favourite part: "You wonder around hoping to find someone who will help you, not just beat you up, steal your money and you Chitin armour, Wait! that gives you an idea..."
...Yeah? God, I'm enticed. I wonder what this idea will be.
End Game and Leave Comments.
I don't know, maybe I'm being presumptuous and the fantastic idea was for the MC to suddenly cease existence, but somehow I get the feeling you intended to add something else. You might want to unpublish, proof-read, and add that extra thing.

- I'd set up item restrictions on certain links, like when you can take the money for the mercenaries. I chose to not take the money, but somehow paid them anyway.

- It's not very clear that you need to equip the chitin armour; I assumed it already was on once I got it seeing as every other item didn't have it's own 'You can't use that yet/here' page, but had the default pop-up instead, and because you also didn't seem to be using items as they usually are used.

- The whole 'go left and something good happens' and 'go right and something bad happens' trope is not a great one, so I'd try to avoid using that.

- As with the last one, I can tell you're way into Star Wars, and that comes through in the Sci-Fi explanations, adding to them. You put more effort into this story, and it's good to see progression and improvement. While most of this is criticism, I think this is a decent addition to the stories here and is above average.

I think this is a 4.5/8, but because I can't go halfway I'll round up to 5/8 because I do think this is an improvement.

Pros: Great length, deep storyline, a lot of good description, attempts at having some emotional moments

Cons: Story takes a while to get going, having some items with pics and others not is a bit distracting, a few of the story segments seem somewhat fragmented, there seems to be only one right way to get through the story, some strange errors ("scale the cliff down" is not English.)

Overall: Very nice fanfic. Anyone who only has a score of around 150 should replay before rating to make sure you're seeing its full potential.

This is really pretty good.
Despite having three authors, the overall writing is very cohesive.
A lot of the items have nice pics. Why only some, though? It makes the generic pics look a little out of place. Was this one of the parts where three people were contributing? Also, is there a way to keep the items, or is it a must-drop? If so, you don't really need the lengthy item selection process.
A worthy entry to the fan fic section.

It was fun, I enjoyed playing through it. Only one Star Wars typo that I noticed, it is Lirin Car'n not Lirin Car'in. Otherwise, it was great!

Underrated, I keep coming back to this when I need a story game to read

Meh. There are a couple of spelling errors.

3/10

This is not usually the type of game I like to play. I found it to be entertaining.

We won at the cost of my life

The game ended in the middle of a sentence. We also had 7+ one-link pages with nothing but a single sentence on each of them.

I like this ending the best;Ahoot the detpacks

Got all three endings. Not as solid as the first chapter but still okay. It was longer with more choices. There were a few spelling and grammar errors.

I did not know they came out with a carbonite freeze gun. >_>

Really good.

I died instantly. I am the best player ever. :D

This one is slightly better than the earlier one as, firstly, it's longer, and secondly, a lot more stuff happens, there is a lot of action. But the story or emotional element seems weaker and the grammar mistakes are still there, although mostly tolerable.

I got 2 endings

it was good

Amazing kung-fu!

Better than the first, I like! Still, a tad bit linear, I wish there were more plot choices and whatnot.Still, Nice game!^_^

Now that's got action! Good job!

P.S. Anyone know how to make an advanced game?

Hmm, you've obviously tried, but the battle is lacking. Giving the player more than two choices would be nice.

super cool can't wait to try out new endings

I love this story, its original and entertaining

Guys I assure you everything in this game is for a purpose, wether in points or the path you take. So try for the best ending and the highest points.
Happy Stifling!

Not too bad. Has potential.

Play it now.

The second Cantina Band Game.
I'm sorry to announce this is probably the last of the series

This is the best possible score (im pretty sure)