Non-threaded

Forums » Feature Wishing Well » Read Thread

Suggestions for improvements and additions to the site.
This feature was rejected 1/20/2007: See comments

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago

Hey Alex,

Long ago the classic editor had items, and link restrictions, along with the SCORE variable. Why have these been removed? Could you please add these back into the classic editor. At least put items and link restrictions back... plz

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
without those items, it seems that classic editors "encourage" linear stories...

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago

I don't know. I'm not sure why you would need Link Restrictions. Are you saying, it would display a link if someone had an item, but if they didn't, it would not display the link? You could just make an Advanced Game, but leave the Change Editor Settings screen to its default settings.

You can write a story-game with no items, but have the character gaining an item as part of the story-text, and simply have a new branch of the story, where in it they have the item, and a different branch of your story, where they do not have the item.

Or you could simply say, Make a note, or Remember, that they picked the item up, and later, say that if they have the item, click on such and such a link.

One reason why the classic editor is good without variables, link restrictions, and item objects, is because (hopefully they're still working on it) there was talk of a PDF converter, that would number your pages, create links, and generate a printable book file of your game. That would not be possible if there were variables and link restrictions programmed into your story game, as a book can not choose wether to display text or not on the paper page.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
yeah, yeah, i know, but at least an "option" to have that. The restriction would allow/deny a link, and i would of course, have other links. and i cant have "make a note" people could cheat. as well as the branching out, in  my situation, there would be too much branching out lol. so how about just the "opiton" to implement the old settings back into the classic.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
Why? The whole point of classic storygames (especially in contest) is to write a choose-your-own-adventure without any variables or items.. It'd sort of ruin contest enterers if they had a variable based game beat them.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
Sorry solo but classic is classic BECAUSE it doesnt include anything a written cyoa doesn't.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
yeah, but its so tedious to do things... no wonder most games are in the adv editor now....

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
I agree, i say destroy the danm thing.. The adv editor is fully customizeable anyway.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago

Never had these!

ALWAYS was used for making **CLASSIC** CYOA stories. You know, like the old paperback books. You can't have items / score / etc in books!!

If you want link restrictions and items in a CLASSIC storygame, look at Magus !

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
What he's saying is true.  Maybe you are thinking of the 'classic' advanced editor which was expanded upon.  Classic has always been without those.

Add old items back into classic editor

18 years ago
Oh I didnt even see that first post, I ust thought he was askign to add them.  Yeah I dont recall ever seeing them in classic editor.