Non-threaded

Forums » The Parlor Room » Read Thread

Questions about a storygame? Thoughts on Eternal? Any other IF you're playing out there?
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
Sw, a new galaxy has scored TEN ones...  You know your a contreversial figure when a storygame generally held in high standard (rated 7, featured, etc) is given TEN ONES.
tsmpaul

Incredible!

17 years ago
ten one's? That's crazy!
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
Someone(s) really doesn't like me :P
Fleshnblood_78

Incredible!

17 years ago
that might account for 2 or 3 of them. but id contribute the majority of them to the fact that SW is a niche type of story. meaning, not only do you need to like Scifi, but SW in particular. Not many people are into that stuff. many of our current members are but that isnt a great representation of our society as a whole. so id say that people just didnt care for the SW movies in the first place. nothing about you was even considered.
Rommel

Incredible!

17 years ago
Space Opera forever!
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago

You don't like Starwars, did you rate it a 1?

Fleshnblood_78

Incredible!

17 years ago

you are right, i dont like star wars. HOWEVER, i did not rate it a one. i thought it was we developed.

nate

JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
mhm, my point exactly.  I think it has to be directed at me because regardless of the topic; a well developed game deserves much higher then a one.
Sethaniel

Incredible!

17 years ago
I'm trying to think how many games I've ever rated 1. Only a few, I would think. It would have to be complete dreck to get a 1 from me. Even lousy games I'll usually give a 2, if there seemed to be any effort at all put into it.
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
So SW does not deserve a 1?
Fleshnblood_78

Incredible!

17 years ago

this wouldnt be the first time an author was considered when rating a story then. if that is the case. you got to remember though that people on the site have a bigger pull on ratings than just some random dude in zimbobwe who comes on the site and rates a story a 1 just for giggles. your story is within a top group. so id say the main core of people rated it high.

JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
Mhm, thanks!
Sethaniel

Incredible!

17 years ago
"So SW does not deserve a 1?"

Oh, definitely not. I was talking about the 1 rating in general. I can understand the idea of maybe someone who didn't like SW rating it a little lower, but it's a quality game for sure. Check your other games. Are they all overly 1 rated?

Sometimes people are just jerks, too. I know Snow has some 1s, and I don't think it deserved them.
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago

Thanks and yes they all do (except Equilibrium and the Tower I)

Mattias has 120 ratings and only two of them are ones.

Tower two has only one one but I know thats from Rommel and its a grudge vote :(

JBCS has some ones as well.

None as bad as SW though.

And yeah, snow definately does not deserve any ones.

EndMaster

Incredible!

17 years ago
I remember when you gave Ground Zero a 1. Lol.
JJJ-thebanisher

Incredible!

17 years ago
"Accidental" and corrected to an 8, seconds later :P