Any other choice that could be added in?
I think what you've got is good. It would be a bit odd to have mostly directional choices and then something action-based.
Added the action choice when I was re-reading, sort of want to make sure the reader can make almost any choice (at this stage anyway).
Are the names good?
Yeah. No need to translate ordinary words into other languages just to fantasy it up.
Good to hear! Not that easy to get good things out of google translate.
How is the detail?
Pages are not too long. Check Eternal. XD
And Eternal got a great rating!
I like the amount of detail given on the directional choices. Much more interesting than if you'd simply told me to pick Chasm or Cathedral. I feel like the details you've given mean I'm not just picking randomly, I can actually make a guess as to where the story might go if I head one way versus another.
That's what I was going for, I wanted the reader to know why their character would be making one choice over another. Or for the reader to at least know where it is they are going. Not thinking "Is the chasm a pit? Or some sort of beast?".
How is the starting point?
Oh god yes of course you don't have to start at the protagonist's childhood.
Eternal did... But more on not starting at childhood later.
Any suggestions for coming up with names for people?
. . . be better at naming? XD Seriously, I wouldn't use a fantasy generator for this story. Since you've made the choice to use plain English for the place names, I'd find names like Rothilion and Phraan (what I got with the first generator I tried) out of place and kinda silly.
That would sound out of place, might make something story wise explain the lack of names! (ie. Light Bearer isn't a name, but its what she is called).
What exactly do you mean by "generic stuff won't fit a darker setting?" You could always pull a GRRM and misspell the heck out of actual names.
That's interesting!
Any questions I forgot to ask?
You can't delete threads. Why would you want to delete this, anyway?
It was up for around +20 hours with no feedback, also getting feedback for a first page like this started to seem a bit pointless (not anymore thought).
Side note: Those 40+ guests are probably bots.
Bots!? To rate story games? Farm xp? Odd that this site would get bots :/
So what do you think?
(Overall, and specifics.)
Overall: Great beginning. I'd definitely want to read the rest of this story.
Woohoo!
I'm going to be super critical now, because I think you're talented enough to not freak out and get discouraged.
Hope I won't.
Dark: Your first line is basically "Darkness. Dark." Which is a bit redundant. Unless darkness is the page title, which I guess would be okay.
Darkness is the page title, First Page sounded dull.
But the whole dark thing seems to have thrown off the initial description of where you are, however am revising this.
Kinda agree with Ogre on that second line. Tumble swiftly, but keep your footing? That basically means I did a running forward somersault, which is cool if I'm a video game character but kinda unlikely for most humanoid people.
I think I imagined tumbling as something else, that line was taken from a song! But yeah, you aren't supposed to be doing a somersault.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mrlws0Dl49g
Oh, and especially not if I'm wearing heavy boots.
Description back firing! Not too much thought.
I feel the dark night on my shoulders? I feel the lack of the moon? Little overwrought, but fantasy is melodramatic.
Has it ever occured to you that you aren't human? Or that dark(ness) isn't just the lack of light?
Pointless potentially story things aside, yeah I might change that its tone is a bit out of place too.
Cold: should be "you're cold" not "your cold."
Going to need people to read through it at some stage, too much English things!
"They are behind you. The Light bearer, she calls herself." wait, is it they or she who's behind me? I'm guessing maybe they work for she, but it reads like a grammatical error.
Will change this part, maybe they to she, or she to them, will see. Had a special sort of structure going, more evident on the following pages (its loose here).
However no one seems to have noticed! It will just cause me more trouble it seems.
If it was "so long ago" how come they only found me just now?
Going to explain this in the story a bit more, good catch.
Tired: Generally "banished" implies being prohibited from a specific area, not trapped within a specific area.
Ah ha! You are banished from everything BUT this city. Will change the wording so that its more clear.
Locations:
Port Gate: I don't think I'd phrase it as "a division of the Empire known as. . ." It would have to be something like "a division of the Imperial army." I disagree with Ogre, I didn't read it as a prison being beyond the wall, I read it as the wall was once a prison.
That might make more sense, will work on this part and see how that changes. Might even scrap that they are a division of anything.
Kind of need you both to read it the same way, since its not describing something lore-ish but just telling you a fact, so revising!
Chasm: I have actually been to a city that was divided by a canyon. How do the people that live in/on the walls get up and down? (Not a nitpick, genuine curiosity.)
Might explain it slightly in the actual story until you go there.
For now think of Dark Souls Blight Town, the platforms and things. In Blight Town there are plenty of ladders but the main thing is two wheels with wooden planks linked with rope rotating around them, platforms stick out along these planks making a elevator! The wheels spin because a dog is running in it (a evil dog). Won't be a dog here thought.
Ridge: Can't quite visualize this, but you seem to have an understanding of the geography.
Will rework the description, not good for me if you can't imagine a place you will be running around!
Cathedral: How big is enormous? If it's a gigantic church big enough for multiple Priests to live within it, how will you be stuck in a place with nowhere to hide? First you said the Priests absolve the sins of your past lives, then you said they could absolve your past and the light bearer would leave- does that mean she's after you for something you did in a past life?
Enormous... really big? Going to revise that since I need a better way of explaining it. Too vague now.
As for being stuck with nowhere to hide is because it doesn't have abandoned rooms, its large clean halls, open areas. But will likely change that last part to something more lore vague!
Past lives refers to who/what you were before coming to Hope, will add this in.
I get Ogre's point about "if that's all there is here, then this is a really crappy city" but I guess I read it as "there's a lot of other places here too, these are just the four you thought could hide/protect you from your pursuers."
These places are where the path splits to, and are close. You can't go back the way you came, so thats one or two places. Also places past the ones you can go. Hence I could likely add more places (and a map, but having trouble uploading images recently).
-----
If I weren't reading it with an eye towards "finding things I think I'd change" my comments would be 99% positive. Like everyone says though, the trick is somehow managing to keep up that level of quality and produce a finished product. There's a thousand pretty good stories with only the first three pages ever written.
Yeah, when I get the first page perfect "perfect" good good enough I will have a basis for writing more and improving what I have.
As you can see I got heaps of feedback about the way the writing fits and descriptions in general (a few story things too).