WatchNon-threaded

Forums » Feature Wishing Well » Read Message

If you ever wanted to ask "can you make the editor do this?", then come here and post. We're all about the suggestions.
This feature was accepted 1/8/2017: Yes

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

I think we should have a trophy for featured comments. Similar to the posting trophy, the top ten should get non-glowing trophies and the top 3 should get glowing ones.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Credit to Briar Rose right?

Yep, I like this. I like it very much. Much better idea than the posting trophies. In this case it encourages people to do something useful. haha

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

+1 for support.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

It's certainly useful, since it makes people want to make longer and more informative comments, but I worry since it will increase the need for the moderators to read most story comments.

(Also, we would need someway to tally it.)

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Wouldn't make the mods have to read too many comments if the comments were only featured when people suggested that they be. Then they'd only have to read the suggested ones instead of going through every single story game and reading all the comments, which would take forever :p

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Site automatically tallies it.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

... He stole my idea! Shame on you! Shame I say! cheeky

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

You said that you were just kidding, meaning that you didn't actually think it was worthwhile, haha.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Well I did, I just didn't think anyone would take me seriously. Is better that you suggested it really ^_^

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

The greatest thing about this site is the exact opposite. The members tend to consider every member as useful until proven otherwise, and every suggestion gets looked at seriously, even if the idea ends up being a simple fix to how you are doing something.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Amen, Aman. Amen.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

It's funny because it sounds the same! ^_^

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

I like this idea too. It also works along with the +/- thing for comments. If that was something users could do, then the system could keep track of it and automatically distribute awards.

[Members] Trophy for Featured Comments

7 years ago

Definitely for this.