Player Comments on The Knight Order of the Golden Sun

I absolutely adored this concept. Posh, spoiled brat nobility getting their asses kicked whhile trying to be valiant knights as punishment? Extremely well-done. I laughed a lot reading this one and I couldn’t possibly think of a more interesting way to put the lead-in. Descriptions of settings were stellar and I thought the POV switching was very clever, especially since the POV switching was directed to thtose on the opposte side of this infamous knight order. However I do have a few things to say regarding the story as it was written. Ah, the sad job of a judge.

The length was honestly very startling! I was very impressed. But sometimes the pages could get unnecessarily long, dragging on with the same details for a while. Towards the end, I felt like you weren’t quite allowing the reader to fail while making logical-based decisions on war strategy, and I was a little disappointed in that respect. There were only a few grammar mistakes, but something really caught my attention.

The character descriptions were a little uncomfortable. The amount of detail taken into the character appearances was dizzying. At times I hoped that you would cut down a bit at that, and sometimes it was necessary, but it reminded me a lot of John Green’s writing (not in a specifically great way).

As a whole, I did really enjoy this story. The concept was amazing and the writing was gold-star material. Just work a bit on these few obstacles and you’ll have a shiny, new, EPIC storygame in no time flat. Really proud of you for this one. :)
-- At_Your_Throat on 4/28/2019 9:57:59 PM with a score of 130
Out of nowhere, a man by the name of RND Gamer comes and writes 4x the amount of the other Corgi (not cori) contestants. Is this man a legend? Will his tremendously impressive word count help or hinder his story? Read and find out for yourself, you comment-lurking leech. Seriously though, if none of it is copied and pasted, then I applaud the hard work involved in getting to that number.

As the description suggests, this storygame is written to be fun and humorous. I’m glad the author included that note since the title alone is obnoxious… and very similar to 3J’s masterpiece. Due to its nature, the beginning Disney movie cliché is very fitting. I mean, what’s more cliché than a princess trapped in a tower? Opening with a tavern brawl scene perhaps? It’s a fun, light-hearted opening scene though. Reminds me of a skit you’d see on SNL or a parody movie.

I’m neutral on the POV switching. On one hand, it’s a creative way to switch scenes. It’s like a movie in that regard. It definitely keeps you on your toes since this is the first time I’ve see anyone incorporate POV switches. It is a bit confusing at first, but once you adapt it’s not a problem. Still, I’d prefer some narration to give context along with any POV change.

I do think the writing style fits the story. It’s quirky. Although English isn’t the author’s first language, it’s not noticeable. That being said, there are a lot of weirdly structured sentences and I’m not sure if one can technically ‘nip’ at their tea. If the story tried to be serious, I don’t think I’d be able to handle the structure. Luckily, it doesn’t try.

The dialogue and character interaction is sort of what you’d expect from a live play. It’s almost like every sentence a character speaks is outlandish and over the top with excitement. There is also heavy use of hyperbole almost like every dialogue option could determine the fate of the world (see what I did there).

I have to admit, there was a point in the story where the length was too overwhelming without anything majorly happening. I rushed through 15 pages randomly selecting links and didn’t die. I think the author should have incorporated more ‘dead ends’. There’s a shit ton of content, but no way to lose for a long time (unless I just got lucky). The reason I rushed through the pages was to see if my choices really mattered. I know they do when you arrive at the variable section, but until then I felt like my choices didn’t determine much. I wanted to know if making a bad decision would kill me. They didn’t at first, although I do realize they could have just earned me less points.

I think there was certainly a large amount of effort put into this storygame. Almost too much, if I’m being honest. That being said, the funny/weird story definitely fit the author’s strong points of writing. Although it was a large text wall to get over, it wasn’t unenjoyable along the way.
-- ninjapitka on 4/15/2019 4:34:05 PM with a score of 5
I liked this story as a whole, It had some good plot twists that kept it interesting. I couldn’t tell what was going to happen at any point in the story, until they happened, maybe because it’s almost entirely dialogue, and there’s not really any descriptions or background knowledge given. I got epilogue B first, and then I got G and F in my second one (back button).

The overall plot was ok, but I felt like it was kind of linear. It really only divided up when you chose not to do something (like helping the ‘alchemist’). I also feel like this could be divided into several different short stories due to the way that you transitioned from one point to another. There was little deviation between the gender choices, but I could tell that it wasn’t like POF, using scripting, because there was a little more difference than just him/her and the name/title, so I’m guessing that there is a lot of copy and pasting. I didn’t really understand why the king would send his inexperienced son/daughter out, or even why they what the purpose of them going out was, and I wish that there was more of an explanation on what was going on, apart from the short little thing before I even start reading.

There was very little descriptions of where I was at. The most I got of the description of the capital is that is is grander than some other undescribed city. I didn’t even know that Valinor was on the water until the climax of the story. I really wish that you would have done some world building outside of dialogue.

I felt like I had very weird control over my character. I could choose to do snobby things as well as heroic things throughout the story, which is a little weird for a spoiled prince/princess surrounded by his/her spoiled friends. I wish that my actions had more of an impact than just 2 seemingly meaningless numbers at the bottom of my screen. I did like how helping out/ being nice to some characters opened up some special choices later on however. There was a little description of the characters, but it’s not close to satisfactory. There wasn’t really any thoughts or emotion described. There wasn’t really any character interaction/chemistry and one of the worst things is that there isn’t a single love interest.

I’ll blame the numerous mistakes on your claim of not being natively English, but that doesn’t mean that there isn’t any. It’s very apparent that there are some, even without looking for them. I can understand what you’re trying to say, but me going back over a couple of times does take the immersion away.

All in all, it was an ok read, but it is definitely a lot heavier in the quantity department then the quality one. It took me around 2-3 hours to read, which is pretty good. I’d give it a 5.5, which rounds up to a six, solely because I can tell that you put more time and effort into it than the average noob’s first story.
-- Austinc on 4/15/2019 2:11:37 PM with a score of 250
Great just like a book
-- zach on 5/10/2020 7:23:07 PM with a score of 170
this story has lots of potentials and if you hooked up with the right person would make an awesome game but it was a little too cliche. but a good job and there is a lot of spelling mistakes.
-- owen on 5/7/2020 6:24:42 PM with a score of 175
Great game, although a bit short.
-- Nazhfa on 5/3/2020 10:23:27 AM with a score of 320
5/8 - Very good, really enjoyed it. Enjoyed the mix of the incompetence of the knights and the seriousness of their situations. Just wish that the story was a little longer as I would certainly have continued it. Maybe there could have been chances of blossoming relationships and romance between the knights added. Also, I didn't really understand the final section of text after Epilogue B. It would be nice if someone could explain that to me.
-- Ytterbius on 3/29/2020 7:40:10 AM with a score of 155
Excellent story. Well written, with just the right combination of drama and ridiculous humor to fascinate the reader. Well done!
-- Luthien'sLight on 3/19/2020 2:21:51 PM with a score of 175
I redid this, and it’s even more amazing!! I love this so much!
-- Hi (again) on 2/17/2020 2:38:44 PM with a score of 225
I finished with the walls echoing my name and being an exmple to all!! I did try so hard to make her a perfect ruler
-- Hi on 2/16/2020 5:53:58 PM with a score of 165
-- kadeloft30 on 1/28/2020 6:19:33 PM with a score of 165
Quite an amazing story, well written and enjoyable
-- Mj on 1/11/2020 12:05:09 PM with a score of 165
Love this game so cool
-- Millie on 12/24/2019 4:36:28 AM with a score of 105
It was awesome.
-- Mordred on 12/4/2019 11:34:15 AM with a score of 165
Again got epilogue B with probably the highest fame possible
-- Jumble on 12/4/2019 2:57:07 AM with a score of 370
How do I get Epilogue A. I always seem to get Epilogue B or E.

Score - 250
- 200
-- Mumble on 12/3/2019 5:09:02 PM with a score of 250
Very emotional ending.
-- Ryan T on 11/27/2019 2:51:26 AM with a score of 125
I enjoyed it
-- Billy Bob on 11/21/2019 11:16:08 AM with a score of 185
I hope to get ending C soon.
-- Cool Beans on 11/3/2019 1:25:39 AM with a score of 250
Oh this was absolutely amazing. I hate that books like these emd i which i could go on amd on.
-- Malachi on 10/29/2019 1:24:09 AM with a score of 250
I really enjoyed it, but perhaps you could clear up some of the situations a little bit better? I'd think it'd be cool if you could do a romance with a knight and a princess or a female knight and the prince? Just a suggestion and I'd really love it then!
-- BigTimeRush on 10/7/2019 8:11:48 AM with a score of 230
Thoroughly enjoyable read! The storyline was well developed and the characters were a treat.

Ending -B-
Fame: 235
Popularity: 210

-- Sir Oedward on 9/22/2019 10:10:47 PM with a score of 235
This was such a fun story and I will have to go through and play again of course. Your mix of nobility and rag tag buffoonery was great. Much like the other comments, I am in awe of this being your first story. You had typos and misspellings so maybe see if you can get some help with that. But it never took away from your story. Great job!
-- Yandeleon on 9/5/2019 12:25:29 AM with a score of 195
This story was unfair to Ogrekind.
-- Ogre11 on 5/2/2019 7:27:37 PM with a score of 205
I got ending B. I enjoyed playing the part of a spoiled royal leading my incompetent noble friends to victory over various problems arising in the territory I've laid claim to. Good Job RNDGamer. It was a fun play through for me.
-- DerPrussen on 4/16/2019 1:11:59 PM with a score of 175
Close Window