There's a weird thing with how things are unpublished and published. As soon as you unpublish something, the ratings get deleted from the rating, so it goes down to a rating of 0.
Unless it's a featured game or still on the newly created list, it moves all the way down to the very bottom of the category it was in (because it's now at a 0 rating).
Which means it's possible it won't ever be seen again.
There's also some weird issues with the system where every once in a while storygames will just not have ratings for a bit (likely because the system is updating).