Well, trophies shouldn't be awarded to just one person. They should be awarded to many people. That way more people are happy they have trophies. Also, some trophies should be awarded for bad things along with a deduction in MAG points.
Newbie Helper - Have to be nominated (more than one can win)
Quitter (Bad Trophy) - Deletes more than 3 games. (-50 MAG points with that)
Rater - Anyone who rates more than 100 games on the site. One has to be length 8 or above. (Bronze Color)
High Rater - Replaces rater when 200 games are rated. (Silver)
Most Rater - Replaces high rater when a person gets high rater and rates the most games on the site. (Gold)
Low Rated (Bad) - Has at least 2 games published/deleted with a time of 3 weeks with 1 as there rating.
High Rated - Has at least 2 games published with a time of 2 months total with 7 or 8 as there rating.
Best Rated - Person who has ONE game with the rating as the highest average vote. {#.###}
Great Poster - Person who has posted over 250 posts on the forum (non-deleted) Bronze
Excellent Poster - Person who has posted over 1000 posts on the forum (non-deleted) Silver
Best Poster - Person who has posted over 1500 posts and has the most on the site. Gold
MAG Point Milestone 1 - Earn 100 MAG points.
MAG Point Milestone 2 - Earn 250 MAG points.
MAG Point Milestone 3 - Earn 1000 MAG points.
Those are some that can be earned by one person and by everybody. You can have both good and bad trophies. (I know I'd have 1 bad trophy and a few more good ones) So, what do you think? 2 will bring competition but not to much. The others aren't so I'm better than you like.