Non-threaded

Forums » Feature Wishing Well » Read Thread

Suggestions for improvements and additions to the site.
This feature was rejected 6/14/2012: JJJ can look at unpublished storygames and, if sneak preview is on, other people can too. An author who feels their work has been plagiarised can go to JJJ and if he feels it's plagiarism it'll get unpublished. It's not like the author/community can't comment on the storygame once it's unpublished.

In-site copyright

13 years ago
Seeing the recent issue with Dalll as the inspiration for this, how about this: You cannot copy and portion of another author's story without the consent of the author. Violation (after a consideration by the council of course as to whether or not the story is infringing on another author's work) would result in the story being un-published (note: i did not say deletion for some of the work may in fact be original). Pretty sure it's a good idea, as a vote from the council and a chance to defend oneself is more than enough leeway for this.

In-site copyright

13 years ago
Keep in mind, it was 2 AM when I wrote this, so spelling errors are most likely abundant.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

I'm pretty sure we already can't do this. Its made some drama in the past.

http://chooseyourstory.com/forums/message.aspx?MessageId=4481

I'd go looking for similar threads, but it's 4 AM and I'm going to Cedar Point in a few hours so I don't want to do anymore forum diving for the rest of the night.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

how come everyime i joni anew site, a copyright issue appears? or at least a discussion about copyrights......

 

In-site copyright

13 years ago
My thinking at that moment was that writers on this site should have their work protected in some way from being misused by other users on this site. I know I'd hate it if somebody copied my work without asking me so I assumed that others would also hate it.

In-site copyright

13 years ago
I know that JJJ has a guide line for this somewhere.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

Whenever this is discovered, it's normally deleted anyway. This would be a useless expansion of the council's duties (which only really pertain to trolling in the first place), and it's already regulated.

In-site copyright

13 years ago
Well maybe there is *some* work inside the story that may be original work, so full deletion may be too harsh. I'm just saying give them a chance, at least one chance, before completely removing the game.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

I don't see why we need a council for this. If you're plagiarising from another author your storygame gets unpublished, simple as that.

In-site copyright

13 years ago
Well my thinking at the time was that the author of the supposedly plagiarized would at least get a chance to defend themselves before getting the story automatically pulled. It may in fact be just a coincidence and the story could just be unpublished.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

JJJ can look at unpublished storygames and, if sneak preview is on, other people can too. An author who feels their work has been plagiarised can go to JJJ and if he feels it's plagiarism it'll get unpublished. It's not like the author/community can't comment on the storygame once it's unpublished.

In-site copyright

13 years ago

Let’s be sure everyone knows what constitutes plagiarism though, before we start deleting people’s works based on the claim.

 
It’s worth sharing a quote from US Copyright Law:
 
“(b) In no case does copyright protection for an original work of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery, regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied in such work.”
 
Copyright does not cover ideas and information themselves, only the form or manner in which they are expressed. For example, the copyright to a Mickey Mouse cartoon restricts others from making copies of the cartoon or creating derivative works based on Disney's particular anthropomorphic mouse, but doesn't prohibit the creation of other works about anthropomorphic mice in general, so long as they're different enough to not be judged copies of Disney's. In many jurisdictions, copyright law makes exceptions to these restrictions when the work is copied for the purpose of commentary or other related uses (See Fair Use, Fair Dealing). Meanwhile, other laws may impose additional restrictions that copyright does not — such as trademarks and patents.
 
So, just because some guy stole your idea to make an epic story about a necromancer who conquers the land with a band of undead giants, gets laid by his love interest, and has to fight a time warping monster, doesn’t mean he’s plagiarized anything or violated your copyright. It crosses the line, only when he uses your own words and descriptions, like using the same names and cutting and pasting your paragraphs wholesale right out of your story and into his.
 
This is also why we can have a Fan Section of stories about copyrighted characters and why you can parody just about anything you want – and even make money from it (ever watch mad TV? Or the Scary Movie lampoons?).