I liked the second one a lot. (Yeah, the maps were reused, but I only started getting bored with it after 3 consecutive playthroughs.)
I liked Anders and Fenris and Varric. And Hawke. Male Hawke was best as violent or sarcastic. Female worked best with diplomatic. Merrill was fun sometimes. I suppose Aveline and Isabela were the two I liked least, and even they had their moments.
There was a little too much "Can't Argue With Qunari" for me, but I never really loved Sten like a lot of people apparently did either.
They didn't do an Ultimate Edition, so I couldn't play the DLC, and I guess I'm screwed for the Keep also, cause I don't have internet access on my Xbox.
It does seem pretty cheap that they forced Leliana back into the game even if you killed her in DAO.