Any idea at all what it might have been called?
There's been a recent switch around in categories, so it'd probably be in the Modern category, but it could also potentially be in Love/Dating, Family Friendly, Mystery/Thriller or possibly even Horror depending entirely on the content of the story.
Also keep in mind that there is now a rating limit on story games where any game with a rating of less than 2.5 will automatically be unpublished from storygames, so if the game you're looking for was particularly short and frankly, not very good, then there's a possibility that it's no longer published on the site, in which case you would need both the name of the author and the name of the game in order to find the unpublished version.
Sounds like one of AppDude's stories. "After midnight" or something like that.
Anyway he took all his stories down for some reason. In fact I'm pretty sure he just outright deleted them.
Given that he was a Nintendo shill bot, probably just as well. Not a good look for the site and all.
Yeah I actually noticed that it was gone a little while ago, kind of sad. I wanted to earn that profile badge mug from the "secret" ending. Oh well