Forums » Writing Workshop » Read Thread

I'm getting just... slightly burned out, but I am extremely close to finishing my game for good, so...

Can anyone give me examples of scenarios in which you'd have to make a tough decision that would challenge your sense of morals? I already have some, but I need more. If you've got a good one (re: difficult) it would be greatly appreciated.

Family or Friends. So many factors come into this choice. If you could save your friends or your family, which would you choose? The factors coming into the decision are based on what your mindset is. If you are in a high-intensity situation, choosing between two parts of your life is very hard. First thing that comes into my mind: Who will be more useful in the long term, and who will be useful in the short term. Which is more important, now or later?

Who has a better relation to your skillset in situations that you can and cannot handle?

In the worse case scenario, where humanity is on the line - who would you rather repopulate with?

Who will survive the longest?

Who can meet your needs the most, and can you meet theirs?

Is it possible to save both?

If so, would it burden you to save your family and friends?

Who gets along the best, so that minimal arguments are made in the high-pressure situation?

Who could survive without you?

Who would be able to stay calm and helpful in future situations?

Many more factors and questions come into play when choosing between family and friends, it doesn't necessarily have to be life-threatening, but socially and psychologically important to you.

Milk or Toast is a difficult choice, if a man pointed a gun at your head and asked "Milk or toast?!" it's not an easily answered question, if you choose milk you could get a rotten milk you don't like, whereas toast - you could get some stale dry bread. You could also choke to death if you chose a dry regular piece of toast. Since you are unaware of what kind of toast or what kind of milk, it is a tough decision. This is where variables can be the scariest and toughest decisions to make, because it can be applied to morals as well. One religion or another, democracy or anarchy, power or no power.

Power or no power?

How much power? How little power?

Could you handle unlimited power wisely?

Would you be consumed by too much power?

Is having little or no power better, because you do not think you are ready for high or infinite power?

What would you have to do with high amounts of power?

Could you handle having no power? Could you handle having all power?

Even the slightest variables that can be humorous such as milk or toast, when used in the right way to provoke someone - can lead to a psychologically torturing battle between right and wrong, good or bad, moral or immoral.

I always though soup or salad would be a harder choice, especially if I'm being held at gunpoint.

There's the good old Spider-Man dilemma. A situation where you have to choose whether you save the one person you really, really love, or save loads of people you don't know.

Another good one is; Do you try to save one person's live at the risk of endangering other people's? For example, you and a group of other people are all locked up safe in a building. Another survivor comes running along, chased by a group of zombies and he's screaming, "Let me in! Let me in!" You can open the gates and save him, but if you do, you run the risk of a zombie getting in before you can close the gate again. So, you either try and save the guy and endanger the lives of everyone inside, or you just do nothing and let him die.

Also there's a good one from Walking Dead where you don't have enough food for everyone and you need to choose who gets to eat. On the one hand, the moral thing to do would be to feed the children first. On the other hand, the adults are the ones doing all the work, so they need to keep their strength up. Which is more important?

Thanks for the suggestions, you two. =)

(>_>' Toast and Milk, Ford? Really?)

Hmm... 

I know a few I've thought up.

1. Damn your own soul to save the world from destruction?

2. Shoot down a man in revenge for something that happened long ago?

3. Retreat from a battle you know is hopeless and leave your friends&allies to die?

4. What would you do if the only way to save the world was to join the Villians side?

Hmm...morals huh?

Would you become a tyrant if you knew it was the only was to have peace?

Would you sacrifice someone you love to see your own ambitions fulfilled?

How many people would you have die in order to stop a single dangerous being?

The key to stopping Lord Evil of Endgame Importance is in the center of the life tree keeping an entire civilization of adorable, innocent tree-creatures, or hidden in the heart of the guardian of a peaceful kingdom.

The only way to convince Lord Evil to spare you when you come up against him and fight, and then don't have the key, is to aztec-sacrafice your romantic interest.