Non-threaded

Forums » Feature Wishing Well » Read Thread

Suggestions for improvements and additions to the site.
This feature was rejected 6/11/2007: In theory it sounds good, but let's think about it: If JJJ is my buddy and posts a game, I want to give him an 8 so he KNOWS i gave him an 8 (then maybe he'd give me an 8 for MY game.) By making it anonymous it's more truthful. Gotta reject. march

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

I think that the rating should be shown in the comment because without that someone can do something like this:

RATING: 1

COMMENT: This is a great game!

riley

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

well, i dont see someone rating a game a one then complimenting it. however the opposite could be true, rating it an 8 and saying it was not great but ok. i agree, this is a good addition.

nate

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

It could be by someone who hates the person but doesn't want them to know, I guess. Who knows.  lol.

riley

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

thats true, deception and inconsistancies can occur between rating and comment. so, i agree, this is a good addition.

nate

Show rating in comment

17 years ago
I agree

Show rating in comment

17 years ago
Yep. It'l be interesting to see what people rate things, for example, I usually rate short-and not-well-done games 3, 4 if it's better, a 2 if it has crummy spelling/bugs/grammar, and 1 if it is just crap (except for tower 2, which is a relic of my previous fued with JJJ)

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

y dont u go back and change rating of tower 2?

riley

Show rating in comment

17 years ago

umm....sorry about using the text message language, I just got done talking on msn.

riley