Thought we could use a thread for these since apparently everyone plays them now, and at the same time there's such a glut of them out there it's hard to know which ones were good.
In the beginning I had Unreal World and only Unreal World, unless you count things like Harvest Moon as falling into this genre. There were other games that had crafting or survival elements, but nothing with any kind of satisfying depth. I had to resort to managing resources in city builders much of the time for anything like a similar fix. I used to wish very hard that the genre would become more popular and we'd start seeing professionally developed game tackle the idea.
Then behold, we had Dwarf Fortress and Minecraft and Cataclysm and NeoScavenger and Rimworld and suddenly it was as if the floodgates were opened.
Only it turned out my wish was granted by an evil genie who got a kick out of twisting it because now there are crafting elements half-assedly crammed into
everything and a zillion Minecraft clones and zombie survival games and even with games that seem to be aiming for exactly what I want, there are far too many to keep up with and they're mostly unbalanced, too pointlessly, autistically complicated or too shallow, and usually shoved out the door only half finished to begin with. Also, I just don't have time to really get deeply into a game anymore.
Maybe if you guys talk about a few specific favorites and why something will click for me, or at least you get to shill for a game you like to people who may not have heard of it.
I feel like Unreal World is still the deepest, most involved survival game there is. I don't see the simplistic graphics as a turn off and the only criticism I have is common to this genre, in that starting out with a new character is where most of the fun is, and the mid and end game is lacking. Trap fences are OP and once you get a little smokehouse built and take out an elk much of the challenge is gone, short of going on suicidal raids or taking other pointless risks.
The Long Dark had a lot of potential but I haven't played it since they added the story mode or whatever, and I've heard very mixed things about whether that was an improvement or not. (Another annoyance with the 'never quite finished' style of game development and automatic patching...you never know when an update may come along that fucks things up royally, and then the game you used to love is replaced with one that sucks.)
Rimworld is insanely addictive and good but it's more of a classic management game. Minecraft...I guess people still play Minecraft? I don't really keep up with it more. It was fun but ultimately got samey unless you were willing to spend more time modding than actually playing, and the entire modding scene was pain and drama. This War of Mine and Sheltered were fun at first but quickly became repetitive and formulaic. My preference is always for something more open though.
Two newish games that intrigue me are
Balrum and
ICY: Frostbite Edition.
Balrum came out February of last year after a successful Kickstarter. I hadn't heard of it until recently but the description at least seems designed from the ground up to make me want to play it. "Balrum is an old-school, hybrid turn-based, open world RPG with deep tactical combat. Explore a huge living fantasy world with dozens of side quests next to an epic main quest. Grow your own crops, build your home, and craft your own custom items."
Plus Ultima Online style graphics still give me the tingles. But I can't seem to find a scrap of actual info about the alleged "epic main quest" on the store page and I have no idea how balanced or engaging the farming bits are. Anyone heard anything about this one?
ICY seems more promising at a glance, people have said the plot is fantastic and the survival elements make it a real challenge. It's only been out since August however so there's only a few reviews. (Supposedly there's an original version that was pretty meh, but it's been massively improved on here.)
I mean this all looks great?
FEATURES
Experience an intense story of survival in a unique post-apocalyptic new ice age setting.
Influence the plot with your choices, with numerous shades of morality that lead to multiple endings.
Lead a group of survivors, each one with different needs, values and ideals.
Scavenge for items and hunt for food while facing the challenges of starvation, illness, harsh elements and other bands of survivors.
More than 400 pieces of detailed hand-drawn artwork that portray the bleak and dire landscape of the frozen world.
Customize your character by choosing how to distribute attribute points among 9 different skills that affect your abilities and experience through the entire game.
Enjoy the new combat system offering a mix between a classic turn based combat system and a trading card game.
It's $13 so I'll probably grab it. I just don't know when I'll get a chance to actually play.
There's Breath of the Wild which I haven't played but want real bad. I'll probably try and pick up a used Wii U at some point. Meanwhile I'm aware of mods for Skyrim etc. that turn it into more of a proper 'survive the cold North' type of game, so I'm sure there are other examples of that sort of thing out there.