Forums » Writing Workshop » Read Thread

Hey guys and girls. I am working my new story, The Citadel of Virtue, and I was just looking to gather some (constructive) criticism on the plot. It goes smething like this. The main character, Aedan, is an apprentice shepherd when the port city he lives in, Oceania, is attacked. While the city is burning, Aedan escapes, well not really escapes, mor like gets knocked on the head and is saved by a traveler. He wakes up in a castle of some sort, and is brough to a huge decision, that diverts the story into two different plots, The Phoenix and The Raven storyline. The Phoenix story is one that focuses on being the so-called good guy, always being helpful and peaceful and ultimately a paragon of good. The Raven story is more of a renegade story, where the ends justify the means. This story is more of a story than a game, involving less decisions, but still plenty, and more story. So, what do you think?

I actually prefer stories with more 'story, and I really like the sound of this. The only potential issue that I can see is that as a character, an apprentice shepherd is so much more likeable than yet another kingdom saving badass - not that I have anything specific against the latter, I just hope you find a way to make the transformation semi-believable and keep things interesting once it happens.

I dunno, I think it's okay. If he called it something as specific as 'Philadelphia' or whatever than sure, I'd see a problem with that, but I'm not exactly going to be scratching my head wondering at the in-universe explanation for people naming a city by the ocean 'Oceania'.

There's a town called Threefork in a story I'm working on. It's named that because it's built across three forks of a river. I later found out there's a real life town called Three Forks, but it's not like I'm going to go and change it just because I'm worried someone might think I'm ripping off Montana.

It's from 1984.

You;re welcome.

It's "from" a real life region in the Pacific.

Ever played Gothic IV by any chance?

Since the player chooses what they are aligned with (good/bad) early on, you're really limiting any sort of moral choices in the story.  I mean are you going to allow him to do a "good" decision once he is in the Ravens? Or are the decisions mainly going to be tactical ones with your character just automatically getting increasingly good or evil depending on their initial alignment?

Ok, I didn't know about the name, I have Gothic IV, and No matter what faction you join, you can always retain your morals. Oh, and Elder Scrolls makes Gothic IV its bitch.

This only applies if you're talking about the pre-Oblivion era.

Anyway, how far along are you at this point? Keep us updated, I really do like the sound of this.

Yes, Pre-Oblivion. I liked Oblivion, but from what I have experienced, Morrowind had better story. And post-Oblivion looks pretty FREAKING amazing. And so far in the story, I'm having kinda in training, because you don't really know how to use a sword when you take care of sheep. And, for people who have played the Mass Effect or Dragon Age games, there is CONFIRMED romance in the story.

Haha!! My guy did the same thing! And, I think you're partially right on the romance thing. I think it should be a definite option, but in a classy way, not focus so much on the sexual parts, although that's good too. It should just be a way to immerse yourself further into the story.