Forums » The Parlor Room » Read Thread

I suck at writing reviews. I’m sure someone out there has tips for writing a good review, or a template/things to talk about in a review.

Also, a question: should I start with the more famous storygames for a good read but have been reviewed a hundred times, or start with the New Storygames category where the games haven’t all been reviewed yet but they’re usually terrible?

Just review the ones you feel strongly about, one way or another. If you don't feel that way about a story, don't bother at this point. It'll be easier to develop your reviewing style if you're invested in what you're trying to put forth.

You would usually tell them what you like and dislike about their story

For one, don't force yourself to read stories you don't enjoy unless you actually get something out of critiquing them.

Whatever the case, a full, detailed essay review isn't even necessary unless you really have that many things you want to address. It can be enough just to give a few thoughts on the story.

If you need a simple checklist as a guide, just look at all the things that would go into creating a story: setting, characters, conflict, and the resolution of the conflict, along with the technical aspects like grammar and punctuation and how much actual branching and choice there was. Then just talk a little about whatever made the strongest impression on you about any of those.