Non-threaded

Forums » The Parlor Room » Read Thread

Questions about a storygame? Thoughts on Eternal? Any other IF you're playing out there?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

@iqqih , @jamescoker1226 , @Malkalack

:P Yes, I reviewed the new Spiderman game. (I enjoyed the first two more, tbh.)

http://chooseyourstory.com/story/spider~2dman~3arise-of-carnage-part-iii-new-goblin-strikes-back~2e

 

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Well, that certainly did not disappoint. Good job!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Not my best work, but if it gets a few chuckles out of the community, I'll be content.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Oh my goodness yes.

Please....more. You need to review every single Spider-Man game.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I hope the author decides to pollute the site even further. :)

Great work, Kiel. 

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I hope that this'll be what Kiel will post as a review.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

@jamescoker1226 , @Malkalack

As I finished up the review, I got a message from Seth that the newest game had already been taken down due to the fact that Bevan used me for a cameo even though I explicitly asked him not to. The review, while on the game, may not be seen elsewhere due to that ... so, while I still have it on my clipboard, it might as well not go to waste. (Intro to review skipped because it basically deals with what I just said) :

>>hitori kakurenbo

"One person hide and seek," that's what this translates to--or, if you prefer, "the most popular game for the loneliest elementary school students in existence." (This is for when you can't even get your imaginary friends to make it two-player.)

 >>"Hey did you heard a game called hitori kakurenbo ?"

Heard? Surely you meant herd, but would that require a sheepdog or a referee?

>>When i tried this game i first stabbed the doll and i said "bob is it

... Fascinating story, Mike. -_- No, really, the utter lack of detail and answer to my question was immensely helpful. That, or you suck at story telling so badly that my character went into some kind of 'boredom nirvana' trance to avoid hearing any more and only bothered to wake up again once I returned home to play a game I know almost nothing about.

(For the love of God, this is an obscure JAPANESE URBAN LEGEND. How many people do you think know about this? Not enough to justify you writing this without any explanation of what you're expected to do and WHY.)

>>You have collected the requirements for this game it took you one hour for searching.

... Why do I care how long it took? ... And why am I playing hide-and-seek with myself at 12am? If I'm young enough to be testing obscure Japanese urban myths for kicks, I guarantee you I have a curfew.

>>You:"I Need to remove stuffed cotton inside the doll and replace it with rice."
>>you did replace the stuffed doll with rice.

Oh, really, Capt. Obvious? I figured I was going to star in a Burlesque show instead.

>>Next thing is the fingernails or blood.
>>which one to add inside this doll ?

Ehh. Split the difference, let's just stuff a baby in there instead.

>>You:" I Just Need to turn off the lights and turn on the T.V"

Oh, now THAT's a good sign that you're getting into some ancient mystical shit right there, when electricity and TELEVISION are explicitly involved. (>_>' Japan, you and I need to have a serious talk--and this time it's not about the tentacles.)

>>After switching off all the light's...

After switching off all the light's herpes* (There, fixed it for ya. Incidentally, when did you learn how to turn off herpes? I can guarantee you there's more money in the medical field than in literature for you.)

>>You:"i just need to place this doll in bathtub."
>>You placed the doll in the bathtub filled with water.

Hey, HEY! You actually expanded on the scenery with details you did NOT make me warn myself about in an awkward monologue! Careful or you might actually get some where with this scene!

>>You:"I Just need to think of a name....Yes Cuddles"

... Eh, never mind. I don't know what I was worried about. (Who names a doll "Yes Cuddles"? That's just creepy. Does it have a cousin named "No Bad Touch"?)

>>You:"Should i walk out to another room or look behind ?"

Because everyone playing hide-and-seek announces what their next move is going to be.

>>as you looked behind the doll came after you and killed you !

I was killed by a cloth doll stuffed with rice and fingernails / blood (or a dead baby, if you followed my suggestion) ... I feel like I need to apologize to Harry about that "made of glass" comment. At least he died with some dignity.

>>You:"I Have found cuddles !,I Have found cuddles !,I Have found cuddles !"

You ... can't be serious. I put the doll in the tub, wait 10 seconds, then announce to the world that I found him--in the exact spot I left him? No wonder you have to play this game alone. The only way it would be remotely fun is if your short term memory was shorter than that of a goldfish.

>>And stab him using your knife...

Kids in Japan have anger issues, don't they? >_>'

>>You:"Now cuddles is it !,Cuddles is it !,Cuddles is it !"

... This is a profoundly awful game. Either you don't believe in the spirits and you just wasted some cloth, thread, rice, and perfectly good fingernail clippings, or you DO believe in the spirits and you just openly invited one to shank you as soon as possible. I'd like to assume there's a point to this game, but clearly there isn't one. (Am I talking about the urban myth or the story game? The answer is yes.)

>>you could see T.V Channel's changing you were afraid

Ahh, man, I totally feel ya. When that one member of your family has the remote and they're just endlessly flipping through the channels, even when you see like, six different shows you totally find watchable and they're just like "no, no, no, no, OOH, no, no..."

>>You could see T.V Channel's Being Changed,Sudden Change in Temperature etc..

You know what? No. I'm not going to try to be funny here. This is genuinely irritating for me. You're describing an evil spirit's presence entering a room and the frightening effects that a human being is noticing because of that, while they're hiding and afraid for their life.  

I have read many descriptions of this kind of scene ranging from ethereal, to tragically beautiful, to scary as shit, and this... this is just so lazy it hurts. I've never seen anyone so bloodlessly toss out a scene that should be filled with suspense and emotion. Have you NO imagination?

>You Need To End The Game Quickly !

... WHY? I have no idea why I'm PLAYING, let alone why I need to STOP PLAYING SOON.

>>You:"I Need To Find Him Quickly !" You Say This In your Mind.

Then why are you writing it the same way as speech? >_>

>>You Come Out Of Your Hiding Place And Now You Think
>>You:"Where Is Cuddles ?"

... I've been hiding in a closet with a mouthful of salty water from a murderous doll demon this entire time and ONLY JUST NOW, as I'm leaving the hiding spot, does it occur to me to wonder where he is? >_> This is why I keep refusing cameos from you, your characters seem to have roughly the same IQ as a bag of rocks or a particularly decayed tree stump.

>> You Have 30 Mins Left.

Until what? X_X

>>*FLASHBACK MODE*

If you just gave me the instructions at the beginning of the story rather than giving me "flash backs" of something I never saw, then maybe I'd die less. If the point of your story is to kill your reader for something they have literally no control over because you're forcing them to fly blind? You need to re-think your plans. Seriously.

>>You Also Cleanse Your House And Live Peacefully....

Yes, I'm sure the same child that stuffed a doll full of nail clippings and stabbed it mercilessly for no discernable reason other than anger issues and/or a death wish will go on to be the paragon of a kind, quiet, and ultimately clean-living citizen.

>>When You Look Behind It's Satan !The One Who Possessed The Doll.  

... ... What? *facepalm* Just what? Satan as western culture knows him is not viewed the same way in Japan, man. I ... I don't know why I was hoping for some kind of respect towards the cultural basis for the myth you're ripping off, but ... just, what? There are so many other ways this could've gone.

>>Bevan:"What !! I Told You Not To Drip Your Blood Inside The Doll !"

Again, this is just bullshit. You're chastising the reader for doing something that you clearly never told us not to do.

>>Bevan Takes The Yamato(From DMC 3) And Holy Water.

... You took a sword from a video game? I can buy the damn holy water because that is a thing. I don't believe it WORKS, mind you, but it's a thing. Blessed water. Not a problem. A fictional sword which you're acknowledging is from a fictional universe from inside the game? Problem.

>>Bevan:"I Need My Friend's First !"
>>Visit Kiel_Farren.

... Um. Hey, kid I just met a few days ago? We need to discuss the definition of the word "friends," I think.

>>Kiel:"Hello Bevan What's Up !"

I can promise you that if you showed up on my doorstep in the middle of the night, that is not even remotely close to what I'd say to you.

>>"So..What Have You Come Here For..?"

Neither is that.

>>"Why ?"

Or that.

>>"Uh....Ok I'll Come With You !"

Oh, hell no.

>>Mike:"Hello Bevan ! You Need Something ?"
>>Bevan:"Yes I'm Requesting You To Come With Me !"
>>Mike:"Oh Yes...Our Best Friend is Possessed by Satan Right ?"

... >_>' If my character called him first, Mike already said he couldn't help me, so if Mike suddenly has nothing better to do and is willing to tag along just because "Bevan" asked, he's kind of a douche-bag. On the other hand, if Mike wasn't called before hand and he totally expected this to happen anyway, he makes it sound like this is just Tuesday for everyone involved and that means my character is probably even more horribly inept than I previously thought.

>> That Fireball And Led Him To Death !

... :P I guess it was just there to light the way, then?

>>Thus Mike And Kiel Hit Each Other By Mistake

-_-' Unless Mike has a striking resemblance to a fallen angel who despises humanity, I'm going to call bullshit on this one. (Then again, I have no idea who the hell Mike is, so hey, maybe he and Satan could totally pass for twins.)

>>Kiel And Mike Both  Wake Up At The Same Time

Huh? My in-game incarnation fell asleep, too? How? He wasn't exposed to terrible dialo--oh, wait, yes he was.  >_> It's just that he had to recite it instead of reading it.

>>Kiel And Mike Handle These Minions And Protect Our Friend Lying Down !"

... Ok, but if you want me to fight while lying down, it costs extra.

>> I Too Have 'Something' To Show You !".

Bow chika wow wow?

>>Bevan:"No Time To Talk ! Come On !"

... You're not going to bother explaining something about the events of your game? What a twist. -_-'

>>Bevan:"Yeah Dude !"
>>Kiel:"How Did You Defeat Satan ?"
>>Bevan:"Ummm...It's a Secret"
>>Kiel:"Oh...Ok "

I have more respect and empathy for Spiderman than I've had before in my entire life. We've both been butchered in a bad mashup fanfic.

>>Bevan:"Let's Wait For The Next Day Mike"

... Did you seriously leave a script note in the dialogue?

>>THE END.

Thank. God.

>>To Complete This Game It Took Me 2 Days.

I'm honestly a little surprised that you even spent that much time.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

<3

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Oh, Kiel, I would marry you, if I swung that way and didn't have to worry about my conservative Christian mother beating me half to death with a 2X4.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I ♥ it!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
It was absolutely beautiful. I'm sure that if Fazz was here, his thighs would be tingling quite fiercely.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
lol. this kid left a review on one of my story.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

At least he liked it.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
But He Types Like This, Like Why?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I Just Don't Get It.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

How Can Start Case Be Real If Our Orthography Isn't Real

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Hell if I know.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Hell If I Know*

Fixed That One For You, Bro.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Bevan's retort for the fact that his game was unpublished: "Dont Force me to Unleash the Wrath Inside My Heart !"

... What?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

He/She really is the gift that keeps on giving.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I was going to review the whole story, but no. I can make insufferably bad writing funny, but that was just messed up.

I made a couple of jokes, but I eventually just threw up my hands in disgust and gave up. I'll see about reviewing other stories the way I've done his, but after this last one, I won't be surprised if 3J kicks him off the site.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Someone banned him. He's messaging me from a new account asking me to please fix his account so he can use it again.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Now he's demanding I tell alexp to fix it so he can use his account again.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

xD He told me his account was being hacked.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

He just didn't know the difference, lol.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

What's his new account?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Yeah, he's complaining to me about it, too.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
Which story are we talking about, exactly?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Shoot-out At New York City.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

That was brilliant.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Edit: Just removing a dead link.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Did you have to ban him? He was my weekly source of free points!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

1) I didn't.  Don't know who did.

2) He's ZhouYu64.  For now.  He keeps nagging me to tell various people to reactivate his account, no matter how many times I tell him it's physically impossible.  

 

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

You can't unban?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Nope.  I've said this a bunch of times before.  Once an account is banned, there is no way to reactivate the account.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
User was probably deleted from the database.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Having an account on CYS is like playing on hardcore mode. Once you get killed banned, you have to create a new character.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

XD

I told him "No one can reactivate a banned account.  Not me, not 3j, not alex, not madglee, not Jesus Motherfucking Christ.  Are you trolling me out of spite, or are you really just this stupid? How many times must I explain it is physically, technically, utterly impossible to reactivate your account?"

His response:  oh well i am sorry i portrayed muslims as villains please i want my account reactivated.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Like I've said, he just doesn't listen.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Oh god, just on the first page:

John and Mike are standing around, when all of a sudden, John tells Mike there's a demon kid named Satoru, who will drag you to hell if you . . . don't ask him a question? Or if you "look behind."  What does that mean?  Look behind what?  Is he standing behind you?  

Mike, not the brightest crayon in the box (but we knew that from Kakurenbo "I told you not to use blood") immediately says "Should I contact him?"

John says "I'll call you later and tell you."

Mike says okay and goes home.

I want to do this now.  Strike up a conversation with someone, and as soon as they respond, tell them I'll call them later and walk off.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

*snicker* I'd honestly love to see someone try doing a few of the things Bevan has written into his stories. It'd be hilarious.
 

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I'm also planning to ask people questions, then after they reply, telling them "Oh. . . well, let's forget about it."

I also want to see a horror movie that ends with the protagonists agreeing to just act like none of it happened.  Oh wait, that's Insidious. XD

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

xD Yes, Malk. I reviewed it.

@Malkalack

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

<3

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

You know, I've heard a legend that if you write a terrible storygame, Kiel-san will appear and review it. ^_^

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Kiel is like CinemaSins.

StorygameSins?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

CinemaSins fucking sucks in the "review" department, and the "comedy" leaves something to be desired.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I like honest trailers.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I think of both as the same- they both embarrass the directors, actors, and/or plot and characters of a movie.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

CinemaSins has been known to pick on shit that isn't a sin.

That time they gave a movie a "sin" for disliking a T-Shirt someone wore comes to mind, lol.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

That was bullshit. It didn't deserve to be a "sin"...

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Also, a "sin" has no quantifiable value, and sometimes they add on a hundred just "for teh lulz".

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Ah, yes... The CinemaSins episode picking on 300 added a "sin" for every slo-mo moment...and there were a LOT.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

... The slo-mo moments were cool.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Exactly! That sin tally was bullshit!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I kind of want to test that...

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Just remember not to do that thing I told you never to do, or Kiel-san will drag you into reading a Warriors story.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Can I just get dragged into Hell by a little devil thing, instead?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

'And the great lord Kiel_Farren drove out the evil Bevan with his hilarious review. The beast was slain... Until he got banned and made a new account.'

-The Bible of CYS, the Book of Kiel, verses 18:36-18:38

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
Ooh, ooh, do I get a book?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Perhaps.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago
What are we going to call it. Ooh, it should be something original, like, umm, the Book of James.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Nah, that's already taken.

The Book of Mr. Fox.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Do I get a book, about the Rise of the Capy Cult?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Yes, but you get gunned down at the end and the cult is destroyed.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Can I stab Slasher towards the end, because I was the one who locked his post for JJ to see?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Perhaps...

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

So there's literally no way to keep banned people from just making a new account? Or 200 new accounts like that one crazy soccer girl?

Pretty amazing then that we're all as well-behaved as we are, if you think about it...

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

"The Words and Barks of the Almighty Wolf God."

That must be added!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

You blow up at the end.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

I don't really give a shit, as long as I guide certain members of CYS to an empire to hide from WC fans and the scum of Bevan...

And I use Dubstepy and sporks.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Really, most of it is just you on LSD thinking you're a wolf god.

And sporks would never work with the likes of you.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

If I'm on LSDs, Kiel, James, and Capy are. None are realistic, so there's only one way they could think otherwise- drugs.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Bingo.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

So if the police are on our tracks for dealing drugs, and they find the ancient books, they'll know it's all bullshit.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Pretty much.

Hey everyone, we're on drugs!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

http://chooseyourstory.com/story/escape-the-house

Who the fuck does this attention whore think he is, stealing other people's shtick like that!?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Haha, I just saw that.

And the game has now been purged, but I think we need to keep that review around for posterity.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

You're late to the party, Sent. xD

The first imitator I found was here: http://chooseyourstory.com/story/warriorcats~2dthunderclan

The second I found was Derp's comment (the first comment) for this game (first to specifically say it was an imitation of me): http://chooseyourstory.com/story/warrior-cats-your-life

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

http://chooseyourstory.com/story/room-no-666

@Malkalack @@jamescoker1226 @DerpBacon @Chris113022

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
I think your review is longer than the actual story. Xd

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

That happens a lot, Nmel. xD

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
Woohoo, I summoned a Kieltsune.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

No, I PMed him.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

And my attempt to summon him was the first comment on the game.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
Hey, but you weren't the one who left the treat out. That's the most important part of summoning a kieltsune.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

Who knows if Chris left a treat in PMs or not?

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

That is for me and Kiel to know only...

I didn't.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

*tsk tsk tsk* You're lucky James left some tofu out.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
He's just lucky he didn't end up confronting a vicious Baka Nmelssx or the seditious Tacoyasha Hime instead.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

The amusing thing about this for me is that Bevan PMed me the second he posted his story. :P

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
That's irrelevant. Now that you're here, I'm going to pet you, and hug you, and name you Mr. Pringles, and brush your tails, and *faints*.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

Damn Kiel, I wasn't let down by that. Another win. I rate 8/8.yes

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

Lol ... I was half asleep when I wrote it, I'm sure it's full of errors. Where's a "Tacoyasha Hime" when you need one...?

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

Tacoyasha Hime? Is that like Frappuccino Pringlechippo? (Arguably still a less racist Italian name using food than 'Pizza Pasta')

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

No. Not .... It is not good enough. Ahem:

...

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
Ah, but mine had a link.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

TIL.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago

He didn't say "Takiyasha", he specifically said "Tacoyasha", which translates to something most completely different.

You guys miss me? :P

10 years ago
Did you seriously not get my clever wordplay earlier on in the thread?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Savage as fuck.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

?

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

And accurate.

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Wicked sick!

Well ... you asked.

10 years ago

Are we really doing this right now?

Yeah, bro, we is OP beastin` it, y`all.

*waves stick* Damn teenagers with their...words...