Non-threaded

Forums » Creative Corner » Read Thread

Take part in collaborative works, share your short stories, poems, original artwork and more.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
It was shameful what had occurred, and it hadn't been kept as quiet as the organizers would have liked. There sure was a crowd gathered today, but not to watch the usual match; no, due to these trying economic times, the 'Dome had been rented out to the makers of a gay porno. Two of the actors showed up in leather pants and gimp masks. They kept looking up uncomfortably at their uninvited audience, and then across at the clock. It was clear they were waiting for someone, and minutes stretched into nearly an hour before the director swore and gestured them over into a huddle with the cameramen. JUST THEN, a siren sounded, and police kicked down the door while helicoptors shone lights from overhead, one of the cops announcing through a megaphone, "STOP RIGHT THERE!" "Oh, did someone order male strippers?" an audience member asked excitedly before being tasered in the balls. "This is America, scumbags! There is no gay allowed!" Screams erupted from the crowd and they all begain mincing in panicked circles. While the director thought fast. "This isn't a gay orgy, I swear! These guys are, uh, contestants! In a writing duel!" He hurriedly waved for one of his assistants to start some...battle music? The two masked men gazed at each other across the arena, and their eyes locked. It was time for some improv. They had never before had to pretend to be straight.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Story A John just couldn’t take it anymore. Every day was the same bland purgatory to him. He woke up, and off he went to work where he spent eight hours punching numbers into a calculator for some snooty client while watching his younger coworkers move up the latter by schmoozing up to his boss. He then came home to subtle yet barbed comments from his wife, ate a bland dinner that he would pick at, wishing for something different. Then he would go to bed with nothing more than a terse good night. His wife, Angie, and himself hadn’t been getting along for the last few years. Everyone thought they were a happy couple because they never argued. John wished they would argue. That either of them cared enough about the other to argue. But it was always just pointed comments, followed by a pursing of the lips and silence. Until one morning that changed everything. He had the same routine before work every morning. Wake up, get the paper, pour himself a cup of coffee, eat breakfast, then go to work without even a kiss or a “Have a good day!” from Angie. He had given up trying to get her attention a long time ago. But today, when he opened the newspaper, an excerpt from the personal columns caught his eye. "To my future fellow traveler, I like piña coladas and long walks on the beach, followed by a night of cuddling together on the dunes in intellectual conversation over a bottle of champagne. While I would think of myself as being fit, I'm not very active so don't expect me to start taking up a Pilates class or a diet to "trim my figure." I want someone who sees me as an equal to travel the world with, not a trophy. If this sounds like your type of woman, write a letter to me through here, and I'd love to meet with you and plan our escape to new horizons! Love, Your Eager Petitioner The entire day, he couldn't get that letter out of his head. The idea of escaping the emotionless void his life had become, laying on a beach somewhere deep in conversation was just so foreign and unusual that it appealed to a part of him that he had thought long buried. Returning from work, he sat down for dinner, and when his wife sat at the table across from him, he asked her: "Hey, Angie?" John asked. "Hmm?" Angie asked, her face expressing disinterest as she looked up at him between bites of food, "Have you ever thought about traveling?" Her face immediately became guarded. "Traveling? To where exactly?" "I don't know. Anywhere really, just somewhere different, you know? Like a beach, or a cruise, or something..." he trailed off as her lips pursed and she looked at him with narrowed eyes. "We don't have the money to travel anywhere except the grocery store, John. Has your job given you a raise?" "Well, no," John admitted sheepishly. "It was only a thought..." Angie stood up and began clearing the plates away to signal the end of the discussion. That was fine with John. He wasn't hungry anymore. After the two of them had gone to bed with nothing more than a terse "good night" to each other, John lay awake, listening fo Angie's snores and wondering: Did he love her? Surely he did. He remembered when they had met at a bar in their early 20s, both attending the local college for different degrees. He was studying finance to get his CPA, she was in art design to become a fashion designer. He had walked up to her friend and offered to buy her a drink, only for the girl to laugh in his face and call her boyfriend over. As he left shamefaced, Angie had followed after him and tapped him on the shoulder, telling him she liked a bar down the street called O'Malley's. A few drinks later, he knew he had to see her again. With a pang, John remembered those years when the two of them looked at every second they didn't spend in each other's presence as a moment wasted. But then John remained an entry-level accountant, never getting a raise or a promotion while watching countless others pass him by. The job that he had thought would bring him financial security was now his prison. Angie had gotten her degree, but after being continually rejected due to being 'bland and unoriginal,' she now had to work part time planning and decorating special events like birthday parties and anniversary celebrations. Her best paying job had been painting a senior citizens home in a desperate bid by staff to lower the suicide rate. In time, this discontentment and frustration had bled into their personal lives, and the spark that had once been there had fizzled out. As John sifted through his memories, he realized that over the years, him and Angie had gone from being madly in love to being strangers in their own home. He missed the days where he had someone to talk to and actually enjoy life with. The strange woman's letter appeared in his mind's eye. The idea of an escape sounded like just what he needed to feel alive again. It wasn't like he was going to run away to Jamaica with this girl. He would meet with her, talk to her for a few hours, maybe make arrangements for a second meeting. That wasn't cheating, after all. He was allowed to have friends, right? With an uncomfortable pang, he realized he didn't have any friends. Between Angie and his job, he had lost contact with all his old friends years ago. Making up his mind, he got out of bed, padded down the stairs, and dug this morning's paper out of the trash. Once he had read the information as to where he could send his own personal ad, he began to write: Dear Eager Petitioner, I also enjoy piña coladas and long walks on the beach. I haven't seen the ocean in a long time, and it calls to me just like your letter did. I'm not really a big fan of healthy food myself, and I'm certainly not one to judge your body type. I do enjoy interesting conversation over a good bottle of champagne in a bucket of ice. There's a bar called O'Malley's on High and Third Street. It has a nice ambivalence, and the drinks are incredible. Would you be interested in meeting me there for dinner this Friday at half past four? I'll be sitting in the back booth, waiting with a couple of piña coladas. I hope we can have a great time, and enjoy a brief escape from the rest of the world. Sincerely, Your Fellow Traveler As John sealed the letter inside an envelope, he felt a fresh pang of guilt at the thought of meeting this woman at the bar he had taken his wife to when they first met. But that was ridiculous. Right? After all, it wasn't like that bar was sacred ground. They hadn't been there in years. And really, what was the harm in getting a couple drinks with someone? It was no different than going out with his coworkers, he reasoned. Granted, he never went out with his coworkers, or at all. But that was going to change. And if he changed his mind or didn't enjoy himself, it was only a random woman in a newspaper ad. It wasn't as though Angie would ever find out about any of this. Feeling better, he went outside and dropped the letter in the mailbox. That Friday, at 6 in the evening, John was sitting at a back booth in O'Malley's Bar, wondering why he had ever thought of such a stupid idea. The warm piña coladas sat before him, untouched since the bartender had brought them over two hours ago. Shaking his head at how stupid and impulsive he had been, he got his coat and left the bar. As he stepped outside, he bumped into a woman entering. "Sorry, miss." he mumbled. Then he took a good look at the woman. "Angie?!" Sweat began to run down his palms and the back of his neck. Angie stared at him like a doe in the headlights. "John? What... what are you doing here?" John decided right then there was no point in hiding it. He couldn't go another day without saying something. With his head lowered, and a note of shame creeping into his voice, he explained to her the letter, the fact that he was supposed to meet another woman and got stood up, and his reasons for doing so. He looked up. Angie stared at him for several long seconds, her head tilted as she gazed at him. And then, without warning, she burst into laughter, doubling over as patrons looked at her in surprise as they walked in and out of O'Malley's. "You're not mad?" John asked quizzically. "How..." Angie gasped for air, trying to compose herself. "How could I be mad at you for doing the same thing I was doing, you massive idiot?" She burst into another peal of laughter. "I was the one who put out that personal ad, trying to meet somebody. I'm your eager petitioner!" Despite himself, John felt a twinge of anger bubble up. "You were looking around? Why would you do that?" At this, Angie cocked an eyebrow. "I don't know, John? Maybe for the same reasons you did?" "Fair enough." John mumbled, slightly embarrassed. With a moment of silence, the two of them looked at each other. "So... what now?" Angie asked. John observed her for another moment, and for the first time since he could remember, she looked just like she did the day she tapped him on his shoulder and asked him to buy her a drink. John smiled. "Well, I do have a couple of piña coladas just laying around. It would be a shame to let them go to waste. Maybe we could have dinner here over a bottle of champagne?" The smile that lit up across Angie's face was radiant and playful. "Why, John! I never took you for a man of culture. You actually like piña coladas? We never tried them together before." "There's a lot of things we haven't tried together, Angie." John replied. "I'd like to change that, if you're with me." Angie offered her hand. "Always." John took it. Two years later "So how are you finding your promotion, John?" Angie asked as she snuggled up against him, the two of them lying on the warm sand as they watched the sun gleam over the horizon. "Being the head accountant of Sullivan's Travel Agency's finances has its' perks," John chuckled. "I guess I should be happy that their most successful travel agent stormed right into my boss's office and made it clear that he'd only be retaining their business if I was the one handling it." "Well, of course they did." Angie smirked playfully. "You are the best after all." John rolled his eyes good-naturedly. "The fact that the agent was my wife had nothing to do with it?" Angie pouted. "Perish the thought!" They both laughed. One thing that made Angie's new job as a travel agent worthwhile, besides John's immediate jump up the corporate ladder, was the fact that every year, the two of them got a week-long vacation package to almost anywhere in the world. As the sun set over the horizon, turning the ocean into a fiery red that matched the sky, the two of them expressed their love in a more physical way, hidden among the dunes. John had to admit that as long as the two of them were fellow travelers, he would be happy wherever he was.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Story B: Only the ventilator and the old grandfather clock could witness how my dear wife tore out my heart. You see, I wish I weren't the victim of love, but I wouldn't have it either way. Since it was our anniversary, I begged my boss to leave an hour earlier at my construction job. A small smile crept up my lips when I thought back to my colleagues widening their eyes with envy when my wife brought my lunch to work. A wife, a house, and in the future perhaps a child and a dog, the penultimate American dream. The sun still hung high in the sky when I marched to our house in the suburbs. I wiped the sweat off my brow while I held the gas station sunflowers in my other arm. The sparrows high up in the tree didn't even cry in the midst of the Arizona heat. My entire body ached once a wave of cooled air from the living room brushed against my skin. A low thrum throbbed in my temples which was worsened due to the rattling ventilator set on its highest setting. My fingers slid across the kitchen table. Dust, crumbs, and a slather of jam this morning. I frowned. In this fatigued haze, I stumbled onto my wife who was just lounging on the sofa sipping on a Piña Colada while scrolling on her phone. It was supposed to be cleaning day. I dropped the flowers on the table. Its cheap plastic wrapping rustled. She looked at the dried-out sunflowers and then at her phone in her hands. With one ear-deafening click the screen turned black. I raised my brows and took one long look at her. The last few times I was this early, she did the same thing. It had become quite a curious pattern. "You're early." She said. All color was drained from her face. Lines of guilt were etched on her tightly pursed lips. After five years of marriage, did she really think that she could hide anything from me? ''Could you hand me the phone, please?" I said in a playful tone. ''Honey, there's really not that much to see. It's also our anniversary, right? I was just about to prepare something special.'' I took one deep breath. A patient man, that was what all of my colleagues called me. I was the last person who would lose their cool if a client delayed their payment or if one of our suppliers was running late again. If one of them had to deal with my wife, things would have escalated a long time ago. Did she think that I possessed no eyes? I rubbed the thick coat of dust off my fingers, flicking it to the floor when it formed a tightly pressed ball. ''Just show me the phone.'' The old grandfather clock. The hands moved, always with a soft click to announce every passing second. One. She slowly shook her head. Slowly I made my way to the sofa, watching if she would for once act like an adult. It would spare us both the trouble. Two. Of course, she tried making me feel guilty by unleashing some crocodile tears. My wife did have the propensity to lie like that. Most of the time, I gave in to her wishes. I'm a patient man after all, but patience is a finite resource. Three. I stretched out my hand and held down my breath. The sputtering of the ventilator didn't soften the loud ring of the grandfather clock. Its largest hand trembled slightly but ended up on the number 5. A sigh of relief escaped my lips once I felt the warm screen pressed on the palm of my hand. I quickly typed in her password and immediately clicked on her search history. At first, it was nothing out of the ordinary. Piña Coladas, cruises, Europe. She did constantly bring up Greece for weeks on end last year even though we both agreed that it was kind of a waste of time and money that could be spent on the car and the garage. In regular circumstances, I would’ve let it go. However, that gnawing feeling in my stomach couldn't be satiated with only half-hearted measures. The heavy thrum in my temples made me want to claw out my insides and search for any way to eradicate that itch. It took one tap and another password to unlock all her messages. ''Please.'' She said while her bottom lip trembled. ''Didn't you promise me that you wouldn't look at my phone? I don't like it when you do that.'' I rolled my eyes. There she went at it again with her therapy speak. Ever since I got us to go to a relationship counselor, she had been weaponizing these kinds of words against me. ''You have nothing to hide right?'' I said. ''Aren't relationships supposed to be based upon honesty and transparency?'' As I took one glance at her messages, my fingertips tingled as if they had been doused by ice water. That one name, the name that sometimes would torture me in my dreams. ''Who's Thomas?'' ''Give it back.'' I held her phone high up in the air so that it was out of her reach. My eyes flitted through the endless stream of texts. It had been going on for at least half a year. ''You've lied so much to him that it's incredible. How often have you opened your legs for him in order for him to play along with your delusions?'' I shook my head. My blood ran cold just by this mere thought. ''Me abusing you and now you are contacting a women's shelter? Don't you realize you're clogging up space for people who actually deserve it? How would your mother think if she heard that you're a filthy liar?'' Before I knew it, she lunged at me with a ferociousness I had never seen before. She threw her entire weight into it, knocking all air out of my lungs. As I stumbled onto the old grandfather clock, her nails carved deep marks onto my arms. She clawed at me, did everything to get that phone, and even knocked my head against the glass. Just as she was about to brush her fingertips against the screen, I threw that godforsaken devil's possession on the ventilator with all my strength. One. Two. Three. The hands of the clock kept marching onwards. One. Two. Three. A long howling wail that soon morphed into a scream erupted from her throat. I squeezed my eyes shut, trying to quiet that throbbing ache in my head. She knew that I loathed her when she yelled at me like that and yet she did it anyway without any consideration and yet she never stopped to make sure I wasn't hurt and yet she just ran towards the phone as if it was her child. One. Two. Three. Nine. One. One. Both sounds slammed against each other and merged to create a monstrous cacophony. They tore into my flesh, into every fiber of my being. I had to protect myself. I had to. I had to do this to escape this nightmare she put me through. She forced my hand. I put all my weight on her, holding her down. Both my hands held tight to her wrists so that she couldn't move. ''Get the fuck off me.'' She shrieked. ''Just, just shut up for once.'' I gnashed my teeth. ''It was our anniversary, but you just had to ruin it. You're so ungrateful. I even brought your favorite flowers.'' She gave me the greatest look as if my heartfelt gesture hadn't gotten through her numb skull. A scoff, then a sneer, and lastly the vilest look a woman could ever give. ''From the fucking gas station, gas station flowers.'' I punched her face. Once. I punched her just so that she would shut up for once. Twice. I punched her so hard that my knuckles ached. Thrice. Blood. I blinked. Slowly I raised my trembling hands. The sputters of a dying fan, the ticking of the hands of the clock, even the buzzing of a housefly. I could hear it again. The reddened skin of my knuckles throbbed and felt warm to the touch. Blood. It was all smeared onto the back of my hand. It wasn't mine. Then I looked down. Her perfect little whip nose was all crooked, bent into all strange shapes and turns. Blood seeped out one of her nostrils. ''Please, I'm sorry, I'm so sorry, I won't do it again.'' She whimpered. I gently brushed away any stray strands of hair from her face. She slightly flinched when I carefully placed both my hands on her cheeks. Her forehead and her right eye were already forming a deep bruise. ''Hush, It's okay.'' I wound my arms around her, hugging her tightly. ''This will never happen ever again, I shouldn't have done that. It was a spur-in-the-moment-thing. I'll make it up to you, okay?'' If I ever let go of her, she would disappear on me and turn into nothing more than a figment of the imagination. After all the things I’d done for love, I couldn't lose her. My wife, she was intrinsically tied to my dream and without it, I'd be no one, nothing, not even worth any consideration. Truly unfair, wasn't it? She wielded over so much power and I was a mere victim of love. ''You wanted to go to Greece, right? We can do that. I'll buy plane tickets tomorrow. I'll take some days off work and then within two weeks we'll be drinking Piña Coladas on the beach.'' ''I don't know, I honestly don't know.'' ''I can even go to that therapist you were recommending, anything you want. I know that I have like anxiety problems and depression or something, but look, I'm ready to fix them now.'' ''You said that last time too.'' Her words were so softly spoken that they were just mere whispers. Her demure demeanor reminded me of how we first met. She was in her sophomore year in high school and I had just finished college. When I asked her out, she was so shy that she could only nod back a 'yes'. ''This time I mean it. So please believe me.'' I looked straight at her, placing my hands on both her shoulders. She averted her eyes. They flitted to the floor and then at the phone with the cracked screen. A few hours later, two policemen came knocking on the door. I welcomed them in with a polite smile while my wife made some tea for them. They both looked carefully at the spotless clean furniture including the kitchen table. Then one of them studied my wife's face. She’d covered any blemishes with some makeup, just as I'd requested. ''I heard from the phone that there was some fight going on?'' One of them mumbled. Just as my wife was about to open her mouth, I jumped in to fill in for her. ''It was just a small spat. My wife just has been diagnosed with anxiety and depression with psychosis. She'd just had one of her episodes, so I had to calm her down. She even threw her phone at me.'' I gave them a nervous chuckle before showing them the scratch marks on my arms. ''Please, I know that she needs help, but I don't think that any more of all this stuff would do her mental health any good. Can we perhaps drop these charges?'' The police backed off easier than expected. They nodded, patting my back in understanding before taking their leave. Still, it was quite a hassle to think up a good story. Nevertheless, I would do anything for my wife. You see, I wish I wasn't the victim of love, but I wouldn't have it either way.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Vote here: (If you're gay)

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago

I myself am quite happy today, so I'll vote.

Anyway, I enjoyed both stories very much. It was tough to decide between the two, but my vote is for Story B.

I liked the tone of Story A and the shift that happens when the couple reconnects. Both characters are shown their flaws along with their desire to search for something they want so desperately. Despite the pull towards infidelity, they are still drawn together as if through fate. They decide to give each other another chance and are rewarded for the effort. It's nice to have a happy ending every once in a while.

Story B has an interesting take on the unreliable, or in this case psychotic, narrator. Not using an objective voice to describe he story is an immersive choice and choosing to use the perspective of the aggressor is quite a choice. I found myself very uncomfortable throughout the story as I had to come to terms with how horrible the narrator is. Spousal abuse is always awful, but  I credit a story for portraying it well. 

In the end, my reasons for favoring one over the other comes to format. Story B is more consistent in spacing out paragraphs, but I also really enjoyed its use of a ticking clock to add to an unsettling atmosphere. Still, I congratulate both contestants!

 

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago

Ok, so unfortunately I read both of these entries:

STORY A: Gay.  A fairly straightforward story based upon the lyrics to that annoying song that gets stuck in my head whenever it is referenced. And yes it is a pretty gay story about a heterosexual relationship.

STORY B: Less gay but has a pedo for the MC. (Any grown man - graduating college - that decides to start hooking up with a girl that is a sophomore in HS should have his balls cut off and stuffed down his throat while he is conscious.) I'm guessing this is Ben's story though, and if so I give him credit for keeping the attempt to use shock value to a minimum - it let the narrative really do its work.  The ventilator and the clock didn't really provide any value to me even though I understand the mechanics that they were attempting to provide in the story.  I found the pacing to be pretty good and I thought overall it was written decently.  The emotion surrounding the spousal abuse was also done well in my opinion.

My vote is for Story B.  Overall, it just seemed to be the better developed story.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago

Things i liked about Story A: 

  • Story A does a great job at highlighting the bore and monotony of Johns life. 
  • Both are disillusioned with their marriage and seek excitement elsewhere, only to realize that they never truly stopped loving each other but simply lost touch emotionally.
  • The slow erosion of passion in many long term relationships and the desire to reignite it is well highlighted and presented. 
  • John and his wife are relatively relatable for most people. His dissatisfaction isn’t over-the-top but rather an accumulation of small, mundane disappointments, which makes it feel authentic.
  • A satisfying and uplifting conclusion (although I'd argue the part about the job promotions at the end wasn't that necessary).

Things i didn't like about Story A:

  • It would have been nice to see more internal conflict from John regarding his decision to meet the mysterious AD lady. He justifies his actions a bit too quickly, without allowing the reader to see him internally wrestle before making a decision.
  • Although the ending is happy, it feels a bit too convenient, especially with the sudden inclusion of job promotions.

Things i liked about Story B:

  • Deep psychological exploration of a manipulative and abusive husband. Double points for doing this authentically and realistically, showing the husband's rationalization for his actions.
  • Great tension and atmosphere created through the grandfather clock and ventilator, adding an almost haunting effect.
  • The husband's self delusions and his belief that he is the victim, even as he exerts control over his wife, feel disturbingly realistic.
  • Memorable ending. The police showing up and then just leaving despite it being a sad conclusion creates a desperate, tense, and abusive situation. This makes the story feel painfully accurate in portraying how narcissistic personalities rationalize their actions. I would recommend it to others just to provide insight into how these types of people think.

Things i didn't like about Story B:

  • Potentially too dark and unsettling for some readers? I am not sure.
  • I really liked Story B, especially the deep psychological exploration of the narcissistic husband. His inner monologue about being incapable of letting his wife go because it would strip him of his very identity demonstrates a deep understanding of human psychology on the author’s part. Very intelligent writing.

Vote: Story B

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Honestly somewhat disappointed by the very hetero nature of these stories. I was expecting some kind of gay extravaganza, yet the gayest thing about the whole contest is one gaywad dropping out.

Story A is really well done. It is a solid retelling of an old favorite song, and gives it an even happier ending than the song itself. The demonstration of how the relationship slowly faded away, and the overwhelming boredom and tedium of day-to-day life.

Story B is also very well written for a telling a horrible story. The emotional impact and description feels very real and emotinoally impactful. The fine details of how both the husband and wife were being abusive and dismissive of each other as people are gut-wrenching. The use of the grandfather clock and ventilator as onomonopoetic impact devices to build tension and emphasize various actions is a very nice means of doing so. However, this also highlights my biggest issue with this story: There is no reason given for why the ventilator is there. If someone is on a ventilator, they aren't doing much of anything, so we know the ventilator is not for either the husband or the wife, but there is no mention of who is on the ventilator and why they aren't a witness to what occured, or that being in the role of a care-giver is weighing on one or the other of these terrible people. If there is no invalid on it, why is the ventilator there at all. The beats of the grandfather clock could have been used by themselves.

I vote for Story A.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
It was a prompt that was almost completely gay-proof! I'm proud of it.

I have a suspicion that "ventilator" there refers to one of the other meanings of the word, but I feel like it might give something away to discuss why right now.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
I look forward to understanding what other meaning it could mean.


1.
cause air to enter and circulate freely in (a room, building, etc.).
"ventilate the greenhouse well"
Similar:
aerate
air
oxygenate
air-condition
fan
freshen
refresh
cool
(of air) purify or freshen (something) by blowing on or through it.
"a colossus ventilated by the dawn breeze"
2.
use a machine or device to support or replace the breathing of (a person who is ill, injured, or anesthetized); subject to artificial respiration.
"the patient was sedated and ventilated"
archaic
oxygenate (the blood).
3.
discuss or examine (an opinion, issue, or complaint) in public.
"he used the club to ventilate an ongoing complaint"

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Even urban dictionary didn't come up with an alternate meaning that makes sense in this scenario

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

To clear things up, I meant a ground fan. Ground fans can be translated in Dutch as ventilators. I made a dumb mistake in thinking that ventilator in Dutch is the same thing as an English one lolol.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Yeah, I was surprised neither of them picked up on it being a language issue when looking at the definitions, knowing who the contestants were. Or potentially were anyway, I guess having one missing did leave some things in question.

A ventilator could be anything that ventilates so it's not even technically incorrect, we just don't ever use it when referring to a fan.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
I just figured some people used it as a word for a fan, lol. Not too hard to believe there are words I don't know

Thunderdome: the Gay One

one month ago

I was originally going to do my grammar nazi routine within this post, but it took so long to figure out how to format this part the way I wanted that I have decided to just post it now and potentially do that later.

First off, I'd like to say kudos to you both. These are solid entries; the Thunderdome has come a long way from its rocky beginning. I enjoyed both stories and honestly had a difficult time picking one to vote for. Ultimately I had to go with Story B due the stunning characterization of the narrator, but I think I could swing either way here.

Story A

Overall Thoughts -

This story is pretty heartwarming and humorous at times— my kind of tale.

Plot -

Positives

  • The reveal of the personal ad and John’s response to it is an excellent way to highlight his emotional crisis. I knew from the moment it was mentioned that he'd be taking the offer, but I like how you drew it out and showed us more reason for him to do so before the decision was made.
  • The twist near the end where Angie reveals that she was the one behind the ad adds a comedic touch that breaks the tension. It's a nice, refreshing turn in the story.

Negatives

  • The conflict between John and Angie could use a few more hints earlier in the story to emphasize how deep their emotional disconnect goes
  • I also think the turn-around with Angie and John happened too quickly. There needed to be more discussion about what was wrong in their marriage before everything became fine and dandy again. Honestly, the ending seemed very rushed.

Characters -

Positives

  • John's as a relatable character. He feels stuck and bored, which are things everyone has experienced. His desire for change feels real and understandable.
  • The twist reveals Angie's hidden feelings adds depth and complexity to her. I appreciate that she’s not just a passive participant in the relationship.
  • The way their past love story is briefly revisited (their first meeting, the lost connection) enhances their reunion later on.

Negatives

  • It would be great to have a little more insight into Angie’s perspective on things. Her motivations for the personal ad could be fleshed out better. If the beginning had a bit of a faster pace and used less words, you could possibly have incorporated an explanation on her part or a POV shift with flashbacks, but at least some hints earlier on that she was also unhappy would be great.
  • Setting -

    Positives

    • The setting of O'Malley's bar is described well.
    • The final scene on the beach, as the two of them share a peaceful moment together, is a good way to give the reader a sense of closure. The ocean and the setting sun serve as a metaphor for their emotional reset, yeah?

    Negatives

    • There could be more sensory detail for their home.

    Writing Style -

    Positives

    • The writing flows smoothly; I'd say this is something you do better in your story than the other fucker in his.
    • Dialogue is natural; I could hear actual people talking like that. Very nice. Also, the way they communicate (or fail to) adds to the frustration of their relationship.
    • The twist in the final scene is handled with humor and relief, which adds a nice layer of irony to the story’s resolution.

    Negatives

    • Some sentences could use a little tightening, as there are a few moments where the narrative drags slightly— especially when detailing John’s thoughts and frustrations.

    SPAG -

    Positives

    • The grammar and punctuation are solid overall, and the narrative’s rhythm is consistent.

    Negatives

    • A few sentences could benefit from more varied sentence structure. This would help maintain reader interest, especially during the more reflective parts of the story.
    • Be mindful of occasional awkward phrasing, like “the idea of escaping the emotionless void his life had become,” which, while poetic, might feel a bit overdone.
    • There are moments when subject-verb agreement needs a little attention, particularly when sentences grow longer and more complex.
    • It's spelled "ladder" when you're talking about the noun
    • There's a lot of "was" use in this story. Try to stick to active voice to make your story more engaging.
    • Adverbs, specifically all those pesky "-ly" words, are inadvisable.

     

     

    Story B

    Overall Thoughts -

    This story is an emotionally charged and deeply unsettling exploration of domestic abuse, with the narrator’s psychological descent taking center stage. The unreliable narrator is done really, really well.

    Plot -

    Positives

    • You do a good job of building tension right from the very beginning.
    • The way you slowly show us the insanity of the narrator is really unsettling. That's a compliment.
    • The scene near the end with the narrator jumping in to lie to the cops left me with my mouth open in shock. It was really unnerving and honestly a horrifying thought.
    • The circular structure here is used really well— rereading the first line after everything that happens in the story really drives home the emotional impact.

    Negatives

    • The pacing could be more consistent. The narrator’s violent outburst feels pretty abrupt; a more gradual buildup could heighten the emotional tension leading to that moment.
    • It would be beneficial to plant more hints of previous abuse earlier in the story to show that the relationship’s toxicity has been building over time, again to help it all feel less abrupt.

    Characters -

    Positives

    • The narrator is incredibly done. His delusions, self-pity, and manipulative behavior are revealed gradually, making his psychological unraveling chilling.
    • The portrayal of the abuser’s psychology (gaslighting, self-justification, and emotional manipulation) is highly effective and disturbing. Some of his lines of dialogue really, really sound like my mom.
    • Small details, such as the narrator’s behavior (buying flowers at a gas station, preparing the house), reveal the complexity of his character and the controlling nature of the relationship.

    Negatives

    • The wife’s character could be fleshed out more. Flashbacks to earlier moments in the relationship or more insight into her internal struggles would provide depth and show her perspective on their marriage.
    • The narrator’s background could be expanded to show how his controlling behavior developed, but that really is a nitpick. His character is amazing.

    Setting -

    Positives

    • The room they're in is described pretty well; I have a sense for what the world around them is like.
    • Sensory details like heat, dust, and air conditioning amplify the oppressive mood, reinforcing the themes of entrapment. It all fits together very nicely.

    Negatives

    • Yeah, I got nothing for ya here.

    Writing Style -

    Positives

    • The fragmented sentences and short paragraphs reflect the narrator’s unstable mind and make the whole thing more suspenseful.
    • Repetition of motifs (e.g., ticking clock, counting) adds a rhythmic quality to the narration. It's a cool device to use and really fits the tone.
    • The narrator's internal monologue is a powerful tool for revealing the narrator’s less-than-optimal mental state; it gives me direct access to his twisted justifications and manipulative thoughts. Reading this directly from the perspective of the abuser was a trip, and I mean that in a good way.

    Negatives

    • You tend to be overly wordy in some areas, making the sentences a little confusing.

    SPAG -

    Positives

    • The overall rhythm of the narrative is solid.

    Negatives

    • A few sentences are slightly awkward or overly wordy
    • Could use some more varying of sentence structure
    • Pay attention to subject-verb agreement; make sure that singular subjects are paired with singular verbs and plural subjects with plural verbs; it can be tricky when the subject is collective or there is a complex sentence structure, so be careful with those.

    • Try to avoid misplaced and dangling modifiers.

    • I think you mean "I wouldn't have it any other way", and that bothers me.
    • Adverbs are not your friends in creative writing. Try not to tack "-ly" onto the ends of words.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
This is a tough one. I think I will have to vote for Story B.

Story A was written decently enough. Having a typo in the second sentence of your story is a bad look though (ladder, not latter). The plot, though sweet, was a bit predictable. Despite that, the ending managed to bring a smile to my face.

Story B constantly kept me guessing. The narrator starting with the sentence that he was the victim of love made me think that he was some poor man who was having a terrible time in his relationship. But as the story went on, I saw how psychotic and manipulative he was. Reading the same proclamation that he was a victim of love at the end filled me with a completely different emotion, and I thought that was a masterful way to end the story.

So yeah, story B for me. I'm not gay though, so I don't know if this vote really counts.

P.S. One small nitpick in story B. If I was a cop and was called in to investigate domestic violence, I would 100% check if anyone was wearing make-up to cover up bruises ToT

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Both stories A and B were really good, but my vote goes to Story B if only for deviating more from the original song, to the point where it transforms the song's story into a much more terrifying one.

Story A.

This story follows the structure of the song to a tee. But at the same time, it does a great job of expanding upon and making us feel for the main character. Lines like "I was tired of my lady" and "we've been together too long", appear, except that rather than just telling us these facts like they did in the song, the author makes good use of the story format to show us how John is feeling and dealing with this situation.

The first 3 paragraphs do a great job of making me feel that John and Angie's marriage is like a "worn out recording, of a favorite song."

For this prompt, one major tricky aspect is introducing an element of surprise when your story is inspired by well known song made 45 years ago. Naturally that weakens the punch of the twists, which makes this a very interesting prompt to write for. Despite this, the story did such a good job that even though the twist was already known, you still felt a sense of surprise on behalf of the character, since Ben did a great job making us empathize with John. We feel his mixed feelings, his guilt at "cheating" on his wife, and his attempts to rationalize what he's doing.

The ending was really heartwarming and happy. Overall, this is a great Thunderdome entry and it answers the prompt wonderfully.

Story B

Story B takes an interesting approach to the prompt. For one thing, at first glance it doesn't seem like it's inspired from the Pina Colada song at all.

The Pina colada song is a light hearted tale about 2 people accidentally "cheating" on one another, and by doing so, discovering parts of their S.O.'s that they didn't even know existed. While this story is a dark tale about an abusive husband.

But in a way, the story is similar to the Pina colada story, and it plays with our expectations. I like how the guy on her phone is labeled "Thomas", initially we expect the "Pina Colada" twist where it turns out the guy she's texting was him all along, but it never comes.

And that, in a way, was the real twist! Darius did a great job subverting our expectations and by making the MC the bad guy. At first, we feel sorry for him since his wife seems really rude, but when you read it again, the way she talks is reminiscent of abuse victims. And it turns out that she was actually trying to contact someone and get help. She wasn't cheating on him but she wanted to escape since the MC is abusive. And it was extra creepy when we find out they had originally met when she was in high school. Darius writes the unequal power dynamic well, and despite the main character's internal narration, we the audience, know the truth about this twisted relationship. It ends on a sad note and leaves you hoping she gets out of the relationship.

Nicely done!

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Voting for Story A.

Thunderdome: the gay one

one month ago
Voting B. And shouldn't this thread be pinned now? The old one is still up there.

Story A was good too and I think I actually enjoyed it more, but B handled an unexpected and disturbing subject really well which takes some ability. "Villain protagonists" are not something I usually enjoy, but this managed to highlight how manipulative and evil they were without feeling like an immature author self insert.

Thunderdome: the gay one

26 days ago
My vote is for B, A seemed to drag out a little too long to hold my attention. They were both good though.

Thunderdome: the gay one

26 days ago
I vote story A.

Because it had gay poo-poo numbers in it, which was probably part of the prompt.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Whoops, let this one sit a little longer than intended. As the cops laid the beatdown on the audience, a lone figure lowered himself down from the helicoptor on a rope ladder. He wore an oversized coat made of Dalmation puppies, and walked smugly over to survey the carnage. An assistant hurried over to give him a white Persian cat to stroke with a cybernetic hand, and another helped him remove his fur coat--revealing underneath, a hot dog suit! "Yes, it was meeee all along!" RK sneered. "I never took part in your despicable orgy, I called the cops myself! I hope you like the climate in El Salvador, you pillow biting soap droppers! Try being GAY and DEPRESSED in PRISON! ...get it? I name dropped my own title! Oh my goodness, I'm so evil! Heh heh heeeeh!" "And now, Darius, Ben, it's time for...um, which one of you is which?" Just at that instant in the pit below, one of the figures was knocked out cold by an...well, one of the props the director brought for the original show, let's not go into detail. The last man standing triumphantly ripped off his mask, and revealed himself to be Darius, with Story B! In the meantime, someone had approached RK and said that they didn't want to go to prison, and that he was being mean. "Oh...oh gosh. I guess I can understand not wanting to go to prison. You're right! I'm sorry, I didn't mean anything by it. I don't want there to be anyone sad, we can all be good friends!" With that, he asked the cops to please leave. And everyone started dancing. Congrats to Darius! And thanks a bunch to both of you. RK unfortunately didn't have time to finish his, but it was great match regardless with the stories taken in wildly different directions and both of you going pretty far outside your usual style. Some really nice feedback on all these too, so thanks also to everyone who took the time to vote. Both authors be sure and reply here for your commendations.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Commended by Mizal on 2/11/2025 7:07:58 AM

Thank you mizal for hosting it and everyone for voting! :)

As for Ben, it must have been a bit awkward to lose after you made a whole fanfic and poem how you were gonna defeat me. Or in the other words, crawl back and grovel bwahah.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Commended by Mizal on 2/11/2025 7:08:05 AM

Thanks to Mizal for hosting this, and thank you to everyone for voting! I appreciate the feedback on my stories!

And Darius, aside from being clearly the gayest member of CYS, you constantly whine about my work being "poorly-written" and yet both times we've matched up, a lot of voters have made it clear it's difficult to decide between the two of us. Congratulations on the victory, and glad to see you're no longer complaining about the "fanfic" like a hooker who got shortchanged.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Sure hope you're not going to be completely crushed when you're beat this weekend, too.
@Mizal just making sure you remember that Ben here signed himself up to lose again. :P

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
I'm excited for this match, should be very interesting!

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

As long as you don't get super angry when you win, sure. 

On a serious note, I enjoy your writing. This will be fun regardless of the situation.

Thunderdome: the gay one

22 days ago
I haven't forgotten, the prompts for these are going out tonight and will be due Monday night.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

Dude, I wouldn't have been so petty if you hadn't boasted about winning against me so much. That ego of you smells. You know what also smells? Your writing. To even tie against me in a short-story-duel is a sign it reeks of garbage. You tied and then fucking lost to a person who lost to a fucking teenager.

Maybe it's because of all that wound licking you're doing, but bring some bandages because I see all those maggot festering sores on you, you sore face loser Lol

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Just kiss and make up, will you?

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

Only for you Ogre haha :)

Thunderdome: I Like Ogre

25 days ago
Nothing much to say about these entries but I like Ogre

Thunderdome: I Like Ogre

25 days ago
I like Ogre too.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

I like Ogre

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

For someone who won, you seem to be madder about this than I am.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

Congrats Darius!  You wrote the less gay story!

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

Congratulations Darius and kudos to you as well Ben! You both wrote stories worth commending.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Wow congratulations to Darius! Good job winning!

I'm really sorry for flaking. I initially signed up because I expected to finish my story by Sunday. I had an idea and I was working on it on Saturday, but then IRL things happened and I was scrambling to finish monday night. I had an exam the next day that I was studying for most of Monday so at that point I was just called it quits.

It sucks because I was really excited about this prompt. As usual, I love the way Mizal does the introductions though. To make a Disney reference, in that story I was like a cybernetic mix of Lady Tremaine and Cruella de Vil, who's also apparently really homophobic. That made me laugh.

I'll still drop my story in the creative corner. Please check it out, and as you're reading it, pretend like it was submitted on time.

Good job to Ben and Darius for submitting and writing really good stories. I enjoyed both stories a lot, and I can't wait to give my reviews and feedback!

I hope to do another thunder dome in the future later on, and next time I won't flake.

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

Well, flaking out on the thunderdome still makes you much gayer than both Ben and Darius.

Thunderdome: the gay one

24 days ago
In most cases yes, but I think the fanfic Ben wrote still made avoiding this one the only dignified act possible. There was obviously going to be some sketchy stuff going on in that ring, the scandal would've followed his whole career!

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago
Commended by EndMaster on 2/11/2025 5:27:49 PM

Thunderdome: the gay one

25 days ago

This needs to be commended lol