The whole site will get a big facelift soon, and I'll post works in progress as they come in. Right now, I have someone working on a new look... so I too am very curious what it will be. I left it pretty open w/ the designer, but I said that I loved this drawing (except for the fact that it's so unfinished looking), and that a retro victorian (steam punk / parlour room) look could just hit the spot. I think that's what we were trying to go for back in... jeeze... 2002.
What I can say is that at least half of you who spends a ton of time here will dislike it, no matter what it is. It's human nature, and we're human. I hated the new major Microsoft Office (2007) changes, and hated the Windows changes (Vista)... but by the time 2010 and Windows 7 rolled out, I liked it. It really is superior. That being said, I absolutely hate Window 8... seriously, no start button!?
But, it has to happen. It's outdated, doesn't work on mobile phones, etc. The storygames that you guys build are incredible pieces of fiction, and the current look & feel just doesn't do them justice --- visitors to the site get turned off by the abbrasive look, and that means less people read your work.
That said, I do hope that some elements of CYS stick around -- but regardless, i'll make sure to bury plenty of easter eggs and retro bits for you guys to find :-)