I think it's more confusing than anything really, I mean you've been around almost a year now and have read quite a few storygames, that one was never making it above a 3/8. But at the end of the day most people probably just saw it as a free point, making a new thread about it may not have been the move.
The best way to move forward on a writing site is to maybe do some writing (with more effort put in), make some meaningful contributions. There's an ongoing contest, you could go and write something for it that isn't 1500ish words of random humor. If you really want to make it up to TCat specifically, you could leave a commendable review on a storygame of hers.