Forums » Writing Workshop » Read Thread

I will create a would you rather storygame with 50 suggestions, I plan to make a series on this. I will wait 3 days and I will pick the coolest, most extreme, out of the box, and difficult suggestions. MUST BE KID FRIENDLY

Here is mine
Would you rather Fulfill your biggest wish OR Resolve your deepest regret?

Would you rather be a furry Mormon memelord, or be shot by one?

...wait, too soon?

notices bulges OwO what’s this?

Still just dying that someone in congress had to read that out loud. And the New York Times and all these other outlets had to do serious journalism trying to explain it to boomers.

Okay, let me try again:

Would you rather have ketchup on every meal, or never eat ketchup again?

Would you rather have a house infested with spiders or a house infested with scorpions?

Would you rather wash your face every morning with kombucha that's been sitting out on the counter for a month or never be able to wash your face at all ever again?

Would you rather live where you have -40°F. (and dry) weather every day for three months of every year or 110°F. (and humid) weather every day for three months of every year?

Would you rather have all your food smell like gasoline or have all your food taste like nothing?

Just to have a positive one in the mix:

Would you rather have a million dollars or live a hundred years?

So many from the two of y'all, I will try to not use too many from the same people, but it does depend on the amount I have by the deadline. Thanks y'all for these ideas so early, I could start adding some now if I wanted...

Would you rather be able to fly but only when you're asleep, or would you rather be able to read people's minds but only when you're alone?

Is suicide kid friendly?

Alien, do you really think suicide is kid friendly? I don't think it is, but I know people have different point of views

1. I wanted to see if you would allow it

2. Some of the people here have been suggesting some very questionable things. I wasn't sure how many of them you'd ignore plus I wanted to see where exactly you'd draw the line on this sort of stuff

I get that, and thanks for checking, and yes I have ignored bunch of the inappropriate ones.

Well I mean kids do it

Would you rather eat broken glass or gravel?

One of those is clearly more surviveable than the other! Maybe the quiz just ends immediately for whoever picks the glass.

Would you rather eat rat soup or cockroach hot dish?

Would you rather poop went out your mouth and food up your ass, or would you rather fart outta your mouth and belch from your ass? 

I am not sure you're thinking these through.

Would you rather be a dolphin for a day but have to do whatever tricks people ask you to do, or would you rather be a gorilla for a day but you just get stared at in the zoo the whole day?

 

Would you rather be a plane for a day and people go inside you? Or would you rather spend a day being a model airplane inside someone? 

I'm not gonna include many of your impulsive suggestions. I said extreme, not bizarre.

Would you rather Mizal politely tells you you didn't think a post through, or would you rather Blister burns your hopes and dreams?

haha

Kek

Would you rather have Mizal van you or End Master ban you?

?

Would you rather eat garbage with Sherb, or would you rather patrol for goblins with Sent but he's always criticising your methods? And also he dressed better than you no matter what elaborate dressing scheme you put on. 

Who is sherb, and who is sent?

Hohoho, naive child 

Would you rather watch Blister contend with Aliens suicide shot, or would you rather watch Blister contend with whatever Corgi is doing? Or would you rather Benholio enters the thread and says some emo shit and Blister contends with that?

I meant to say shit but shot looks funny 

I wish I could delete all the ones I didn't like, that way I didn't have to scroll to much, Instead I'll copy the ones I might add to my notes or even open up the story now

Don't worry though, I have one of your WYR saved :)

Lol which one

You'll have to wait and see, I might do two of yours

Interesting 

I'm still taking more ideas, ideas will not be closed in three days, but I will begin to write the story on Monday and I will write until I have 50 suggestions, then I will write another WYR storygame halfway through October, maybe the 17th?

Would you rather ask a dog when you're writing your own storygame, or would you rather ask would you rather?

Again, where do you get these weird would you rathers? XD

He's drunk.

Would you rather be Benholman44 or Alienrun?

Cursed question.

Would you rather be butchered, or eaten whole?

Would you rather be immortal or invisible? :)

Would you rather be well-liked and respected by a large number of people (say around 10-20k people) or be madly beloved by a small group (say around 5-6 people)?

Would you rather be immortal but outlive every living being in the universe and eventually be alone for all eternity, or live a normal human lifespan and then cease to exist in any form whatsoever afterwards?

Would you rather be Black, Female or Gay?

Would you rather carry the first obese guy you see on the road for 24 hours or eat 50 Big Mac's in 30 minutes?

Would you rather eat spaghetti with a spoon or eat cereal with milk using a fork?

Would you rather always know the answer to riddles and questions and suck at writing or be a very good writer but suck at riddles and questions?

Would you rather have the ability turn invisible whenever you vomit 1 liter or fly for 10 seconds every time you let out a fart louder than 70 decibels? Or would you rather hiccup confetti every time you laugh, or sneeze out glitter whenever you’re nervous?

Would you rather eat cereal with a fork, eat a fork with cereal, eat cereal without a fork, eat a fork without cereal, let the fork eat the cereal, let the cereal eat the fork, stack the fork on the cereal, stack the cereal on the fork, chase the fork around the cereal, chase the cereal around the fork, hide the fork in the cereal, hide the cereal in the fork, pour the cereal over the fork, pour the fork over the cereal, mix the fork with the cereal, mix the cereal with the fork, balance the fork on top of the cereal, balance the cereal on top of the fork, lick the fork while the cereal stares, or just give up and eat something else for breakfast?

Would you get a million dollars, or cancer?

What kind of cancer? Is it skin cancer, breast cancer, lung cancer, prostate cancer, or colorectal cancer?

All of it. At the same time. You turn into a huge fucking tumor.

Would you rather be bitten by 100 mosquitoes, or would you rather eat 100 mosquitoes?

Fuck mosquitoes. I would genocide mosquitoes without a second thought. I would gladly eat 100 just to hear their tiny screams of horror.

Would you rather go to Chernobyl and be transformed into a giant monster to destroy buildings in New York, or have gay sex with Putin? Like I do.

Nobody delete this please.

1. Would you rather be stuck on a deserted island and play X video game or Y video game?

2. Same as above but replace the deserted island with someone pointing a gun to your head.

3. Would you rather be a bird, fish or lizard?

4. Would you rather be trapped in a virtual reality that's a paradise or rule over one with other people in it that's post apocolyptic/a hellscape of sorts? (Basically you taking on the role of a Dark Lord and you can't step away from the role) The important difference between the two is that in one your alone and the other you are not, despite everything about the first one being better than the second one otherwise.

I could probably think of more, but in terms of unique stuff, that's whats on the top of my head.

I do have to wonder if you plan to make up any scenarios on your own or if your purely just using suggestions on this thread. Because give how many responses you got, I can only imagine how many you would be able to come up with if you tried, given that this is your project so you should be the most motivated to come up with ideas for it.

I'm looking forward to reading this if you ever end up finishing it! Good luck writing it! :D

What if being the Dark Lord IS your paradise?

Thanks, I'm currently making the list and I might use two of yours :)

Would you rather be tortured brutally for 37 hours straight with tools such as chains, gasoline, matches, generators with alligator clips, etc, or get 5 millions dollars deposited into your bank account?

I'm not sure you understand how these are supposed to work.

I'd like to think he's joking...but yeah...I guess it would be funnier if he wasn't! (lol :P)

Oh, I think I get it now. Would you rather have 100 million dollars, or havr a 50 percent chance of winning 100 million dollars? (I’m slightly addicted to gambling)

I would rather take the 100 million, and not risk it :)

Oh, so you’re gay? Pussy.

Here, Blister, a better version of this that makes sense: Would you rather get $100k right now, guaranteed, or take a fifty-fifty chance of getting either one million dollars or absolutely nothing?

Thanks

.

I would change it slightly. Would you rather have 50 million dollars but everyone you love will know about it or have a 50 percent chance of winning 100 million dollars? Losing will result you going to jail for suspicious activity.

What happened to keeping these Kid Friendly??

Would you rather shut the FUCK UP, or have me come over to your house and shove a pike up your ass and roast you over a fire like a FUCKING KEBAB?

Option A

A fellow masochist I see.

Would you rather the texture of all your food be wrong, or the temperature of all your food be wrong?

'Wrong' being the opposite of what you'd want/expect; for example, something meant to be tender will become texturally stringy and tough, or all foods that you'd want to be warm become cold as soon as you take a bite and vice versa.

Things to consider:
-Instantly melted ice cream
-Dense horrible bread ingots
-Cold dinner on a winter night
-Chicken breast that chews like beef gristle

Sounds like a good one :)

Never thought of Would You Rather as a litmus test for autism, but boy howdy is it ever.

Anyway, here's a few wholesome ones, for the children:

1) Would you rather live in a world where elves are real or a world where dragons are real?

2) Would you rather have a genie that can grant three small wishes every day (like finding your hairbrush or bringing you a slice of pizza) or a genie that grants only one big wish you have to save for an emergency? (Curing you of cancer, etc.)

3) Would you rather set out to travel the world with a magic backpack that refills every day with a freshly packed lunch and a clean change of clothes, or a faithful pet that never gets hurt or sick or old?

4) Right now: would you rather have the best sushi of your life or the best burger of your life? (Sorry, I'm hungry.)

5) Would you rather end all poverty or end all wars?

Burger for sure, lol

Lol, I have three of Mizal's, two of Corgi's, two of Alienrun's, two SpicyXnoodles, and the rest that I have chosen are about one suggestion from each person, so I'm looking for about 40 more suggestions by Monday, or at least that's when I'll start making the "storygame" for the suggestions

There's some simple things you can do with variables and scripting to help quizzes stand out. You can track the players choices so you can provide commentary at the end, or if you have a ton of questions but don't want the quiz to be too long, you can randomize which ones are shown each time. Might be a little advanced and/or tedious if you're learning from scratch though.

This is a pretty fun one, though I think Berka uses a bit of HTML voodoo for stuff the editor couldn't pull off by itself.

Yeah I'm not too sure about that, but thanks anyways

Can't wait to read your story! Looking at all these ''would you rather'' suggestions, it already feels like it will be really funny and challenging :)

Thanks

a litmus test for autism

Ok now I'm curious, can you explain this? (Or is this mainly calling out Bezro and someone else maybe?) 

Hey, I’m not autistic, stop it before I make an extremely long 9 page fanfic about you and that faggot crimson. Would that even be gay? Which if y’all are both feminine enough to be considered the wife then it would still be lesbian…

I was accusing Mizal of suggesting/saying you have autism...I'm not saying that YOU do!

Don't worry though. I definitely have WAY more autism than you, despite the fact we have a decent amount in common. (You tend to wear your edginess on your sleeve whereas I tend to keep mine hidden until I deem it appropriate to share with others! :P)

Do you have ADHD though? Maybe...but honestly who cares! About 50% of the people here at least aren't super social anyways so it really doesn't mean much at the end of the day!

lol :P

My ADHD is horrible, the only reason i can pass classes in school is caffeine, and because i can learn the material before my short attention span runs out. If i was dumb i would be fucked.

Would you rather never get tired again (essentially removing the need for sleep) or gain the power to slow down time?

Depends on what "slow down time" means. But assuming you can slow down the time of the rest of the world to arbitrary slowness, you could effectively pause time, sleep a good 8 hours, and then resume as if no time has passed. The downside is obviously you will age faster. But perhaps you can slow down time on the cells of your body that are affected the most by aging (perhaps fast reproducing cells) while still being able to be conscious and aware, so you can extend your own life. And if you could slow down your o

So, it seems to me the power to slow down time is far superior, depending on the criteria.

true, but then your making the answer/question far too complicated. But I don't really care to much, I'll add this suggestion to my WYR

I need 35 more suggestions for me to complete my original idea for my WYR storygame, I was hoping to have at least 25 by tomorrow. KID FRIENDLY ONLY

Would you rather always cough or always feel like you have to sneeze but you cannot?

Would you rather have the power to speed time up whenever you want, or stop time whenever you want?

Would you rather have the ability to send alternate versions of yourself forward in time or have the ability to send alternate versions of yourself back in time? In both WYRs, you would have the ability to communicate with your doppelgängers.

This is a tough one. Because if you alter your past self, does it have anything to do with your present self? Have you just changed the course of a parallel universe? Or perhaps would you kill your old self and take their place, affording you the opportunity to relive your best moments or correct your greatest regrets? Now I'm starting to think of the movie Primer (btw, watch it! Best time travel movie of all time)

Would you rather have pizza flavored ice cream, or vanilla ice cream flavored pizza?

Would you rather be able to swim through land or be able to run on water?

Would you rather have the ability to speak to a loved one you lost, or a future loved one who you haven't met yet, but you'll meet later some time in the future?

Last one: Would you rather have the power to split yourself into smaller and smaller mini versions of you, or have the power of combining with other people to form a massive combined individual with the hive mind of all the people you chose to combine(but the max is 5 people, more than that and the power doesn't work)

This is a fun idea Blister. Best of luck on your game dude!

Thanks, I'll definitely add some of these :)

Here's a few off the top of the dome:

1) would you rather lose your sense of taste or your sense of pain?

2) Would you rather have any random Pokémon or have the ability to turn into any animal? 
 
3) would you rather have the ability to save just one person very close to you or save 1000 random people? 

4) would you rather live in any anime of your choosing or any tv show of your choosing? 
 
5) would you rather never listen to music again or never use social media again? 

6) would you rather your child be kind but dumb or smart but sociopathic? 

7) would you rather be in a zombie apocalypse or in the fallout universe? 

thanks, I will definitely use some of these :)

Btw, I am thinking of giving y'all credit for your suggestions in the story, either a tag or just a simple reference to y'all. Still need 25 more suggestions, or I might use 25 for my first story, and then create the next one later with more suggestions?

Would you rather: Always get 100 on tests, but never turn homework in on time, or always get 100 on homework, but never go to any clubs?

I'll probably think up more later

Your good

How is everyone doing today?

Would you rather be a wizard with a tower full of powerful artifacts, or captain a starship into new frontiers?

Would you rather die and discover Heaven is an enormous, magical library, or an endless enchanted forest?

Would you rather publish a book of profound wisdom that changed people's lives for the better and was beloved for generations, but no one knew who the author was? Or publish trashy YA werewolf romance that you hate with your very soul but it makes you famous?

Would you rather be able to fall from any distance unhamed, or breathe underwater?

I need 33 more Suggestions!!

Honestly thought I would get closer to 50 by now since This post is like 4 days old... I'm also using two of everybody's suggestions and still I'm no where near my goal for 50 :(

You might need to use more then two from those of us who posted a lot. Or come up with more of your own.

115 replies here so this has been a popular thread, only so many people are wanting to come up with ideas though it seems.

Maybe, I guess I like variety and to give people a chance to help and have their ideas shared

Would you rather be an octopus, intelligent, yet doomed to cease attempting to live after you procreate, or be a fish that lives a lot longer but has less brainpower than an octopuses' arm?

Would rather be a snow leopard living a harsh life high in the mountains, hungry much of the time, always in danger of falling and hurting yourself, or a mountain goat, climbing on the harsh rocks looking for plant matter to eat, always wary of snow leopards or eagles seeking to make a meal out of you?

Would you rather be a male chimpanzee, knowing you will face violent power struggles among the community, but have a fulfilling social life apart from these violent struggles, or be a male orangutan, living mostly alone after you leave your mother after about the first 8-10 years of your life, but be free from most of this inter-group violence?


And since we're here at all: if you lived during a drought, would you rather be a lion, struggling to kill and eat raw meat, or a zebra having to navigate between other thirsty herbivores—including dangerous elephants and rhinos— knowing lions are prowling just outside the gathering around the single small pond of water.

These are pretty good too... I think I will at least add one of these

I think you should have one where the life is brutal as one choice, or a brainless life where it's less brutal.

Like, would you rather be a wildebeest in the African savanna, struggling to avoid predators and starving during droughts, yet intelligent enough to form relationships with other animals, or would you rather be a scabies mite, so low in intelligence that all you can feel is your need to eat dead skin, no real hurts, no desires, no stress. Just feeding, until it's all over.

Im curious where you are getting some of these facts, because they are pretty cool

Mostly The Lion King and Sir David Attenborough.

You might like some of the BBC animal documentaries on youtube, but some of them can be pretty intense.

They aren't to graphic... but I'm currently watching a show about animals on Netflix

*Note that as either a lion or a zebra, you get to murder your rival's kids at every opportunity.

Mizal, me and Avo have a question for you

1. Would you rather be forced to sing along to every song you heard or forced to dance to every song you heard?
2. Would you rather win the lottery and live in isolation or have life go on normally?
3. Would you rather have the ability to see 10 minuets into the future or 150 years?
4. Would you rather have telekinesis (move things with your mind) or telepathy (read minds, both telepathic abilities)?
5. Would you rather team up with wonder woman or captain marvel?
6. Would you rather live in a tree house or in a cave?
7. Would you rather win $25k or your friend win $100k?
8. Would you rather be in a zombie apocalypse or a robot apocalypse?
9. Would you rather spend your life alone or with really annoying people?
10. Would you rather give up all screens for a month or bathing for a month?
11. Would you rather spend a year in total isolation or a year without a home?
12. Would you rather buy all used underwear or all used toothbrushes?

Thanks, I'll use a few of these.

Yall need to create suggestions just like miss Avo's, her's are perfectly written and not weird, and pretty simple :D

1. Would you rather have super-sensative taste buds or super-sensative hearing?
2. Would you rather only eat pizza for a year or eat no pizza for 5 years?
3. Would you rather never get another present in your life but always pick the perfect present for everyone else or keep getting presents but giving terrible ones to everyone else?
4. Would you rather sleep in a dog house or let stray dogs sleep in your bed?
5. Would you rather be able to speak any language or speak with animals?
6. Would you rather have all of you messages and photos leak publicly or never use a cellphone again?
7. Would you rather run at 100mph or fly at 20mph?

I think I could literally just make a storygame called "Avo's simple and fun Would You Rather's" :D

lol, ty

If you want, I can think up some more.

Might as well, but i'll still try to not use too many of yours to keep it balanced and fair. but I did need 30 more suggestions, so maybe I can extend the cap to 5 suggestions a person, at least for this first one :)

Ok gimmy a second

1. Would you rather go vegan or only eat meat and dairy for a month?
2. Would you rather spend the weekend with pirates or ninjas?
3. Would you rather win the lottery but have to spend it all in one day or get your salary triples permanantly?
4. Would you rather give up cake or ice cream forever?
5. Would you rather hear a comforting lie or a uncomfortable truth?
6. Would you rather be locked in a room for a week that's too bright or pitch black?
7. Would you rather have to hunt and gather for extreamly healthy and tasty food or eat unutritious gross food for free brought right to you for your whole life?
8. Would you rather have lots of money or lots of fame?
9. Would you rather only be able to listen to one song for the rest of your life or only be able to watch one movie?
10. Would you rather live a peaceful quite life in a small cabin in the woods, or in a drama filled mansion in the big city?
11. Would you rather drink sour milk or brush your teeth with soap?
12. Would you rather never get cold or hot again or never be late or get stuck in traffic again?
13. Would you rather be tall and ugly or short and pretty?
14. Would you rather go to vacation in Paris or Hawii?
15. Would you rather never eat candy again or never eat anything but candy?
16. Would you rather lose your short-term memory or lose your long-term memory?

1. Meat/dairy
2. Ninjas
3. Depends on the lottery; I could buy a lot in one day, but probably triple salary permanently.
4. Cake
5. Truth
6. Pitch black
7. Define "gross." Would probably go with hunt.
8. Fame
9. Movie
10. Both?
11. Soap.
12. Hot and cold are fun sometimes. Would rather not deal with traffic.
13. Short and pretty.
14. Hawaii
15. Never eat candy again.
16. Short.

1) Would you rather be forced to live with three random strangers who are replaced once every year, or never be able to share a home with anyone ever?

2) Would you rather be locked into spectator mode in real life (basically you're a ghost) or have your brain transferred to the internet so that you only exist as an online presence?

3) Would you rather have to wrestle with a monster made of sewage once per month, or wear unwashed secondhand clothes from homeless people for the rest of your life?

4) Would you rather know other people's futures, or your own?

5) Would you rather have a magical fairy that follows you around and loudly narrates your inner monologue to everyone around you, or have to perpetually take care of a slug that doesn't die of old age, but kills you if it gets further than 20 feet from you. 

dang, I'll for sure use 1 and 4 :)

Ugh. :/ First two are easy to me (I'll choose living alone [can still visit others] and online [free ticket to effective immortality]). But then it gets complicated. For 3, for example, either way you could get a horrible disease.

Regarding 5, you didn't say I couldn't pour salt on it. That's "taking care" of it, in the cinema crime boss kind of way.

I put in another round of 16 WYR.

1. Would you rather be stranded in the jungle or the desert?
2. Would you rather everyone you love forget your birthday or sing you happy birthday for 24 hours straight?
3. Would you rather be invisible or be able to fly?
4. Would you rather start a colony on another world or be the leader of a county on earth?
5. Would you rather have 1 wish granted today or 20 wishes granted 20 years later (with the usual guidlines)?
6. Would you rather burp loudly in public or fart in public?

1. Would you rather go vegan or only eat meat and dairy for a month?

Vegan

1. Would you rather spend the weekend with pirates or ninjas?

Ninjas

1. Would you rather win the lottery but have to spend it all in one day or get your salary triples permanantly?

triple salary (when I get a job)

1. Would you rather give up cake or ice cream forever?

Ice cream

1. Would you rather hear a comforting lie or a uncomfortable truth?

truth

1. Would you rather be locked in a room for a week that's too bright or pitch black?

dark

1. Would you rather have to hunt and gather for extreamly healthy and tasty food or eat unutritious gross food for free brought right to you for your whole life?

Hunt and gather, I'd learn

1. Would you rather have lots of money or lots of fame?

money

1. Would you rather only be able to listen to one song for the rest of your life or only be able to watch one movie?

movie

1. Would you rather live a peaceful quite life in a small cabin in the woods, or in a drama filled mansion in the big city?

quiet, peaceful life

1. Would you rather drink sour milk or brush your teeth with soap?

brush my teeth with soap

1. Would you rather never get cold or hot again or never be late or get stuck in traffic again?

never late

1. Would you rather be tall and ugly or short and pretty?

short

1. Would you rather go to vacation in Paris or Hawii?

Hawii

1. Would you rather never eat candy again or never eat anything but candy?

no candy

1. Would you rather lose your short-term memory or lose your long-term memory?

short-term

Thanks